Q: about silica gel


Status
Not open for further replies.
this taken from Dry Cabinet

Originally Posted by aethra
i bought my canon 50D about 3 weeks back. After paying the shop $2500 in cold hard cash, my heart ached.

I decided that I will save money and follow the "locknlock" method. So I drove to buy a 9L Lock N Lock and a bottle of blue silica gel.

I came home and told my mum that I am trying to save money. She said I was stupid and why did I not buy a $120 dry cabinet instead.

Now, 3 weeks later, I regret everyday when I see the Lock N Lock box. I could have used the money to buy a dry cabinet (about 20% of the price).

Just go and buy the dry cabinet, no need to worry about fungus (not that mine is growing any) but it is so convenient.

I am buying on on 20 October. Thats when pay day comes.

>_< i get the idea, but where do you find a $120 dry cabinet? :L the cheapest i've seen so far, from websites and stuff, is close to 200 dollars.. :/ and i'd still need about a month or two to save up that kind of money, because i'm still a student, and i'm not holding a part-time job.
 

When the box become too dry it will damage the rubber on your camera.
 

>_< i get the idea, but where do you find a $120 dry cabinet? :L the cheapest i've seen so far, from websites and stuff, is close to 200 dollars.. :/ and i'd still need about a month or two to save up that kind of money, because i'm still a student, and i'm not holding a part-time job.

You noticed that there are different sizes? the smallest size (30-36l) is slightly over 100 bucks. for 200 you can get already 60l. Check with camera shops like MS Color and others, some have small dry cabinets ex-stock.
 

ooh! i'll try to check out the MS color in AMK hub the next time i go there then! ty :)
 

>_< i get the idea, but where do you find a $120 dry cabinet? :L the cheapest i've seen so far, from websites and stuff, is close to 200 dollars.. :/ and i'd still need about a month or two to save up that kind of money, because i'm still a student, and i'm not holding a part-time job.

Digi-cabi and AIPO. Use Search function. :)
 

How do you verify this assumption?

i did an experiment using digital hygrometer ...

-1st week, using the 'sd' dehumidifier in the dry box, with my camera &
-5th week, using the 'sd' dehumidifier in ziplock bag (with my camera too)...
-both are in the same cabinet. each experiment lasts 4 weeks.

both readings came out at that RH% i mentioned...

but its just a testing i did, just in case i have to travel, & cannot simply lug my dry cabinet along wherever i go.
 

Can you advise further how to regulate an airtight environment to 39%? Thanks
My airtight container with dry agent is 14-19% humidity (reading from digital hygrometer).

But my equipments are happy.


you could be putting way too much drying agent...
 

i did an experiment using digital hygrometer ...
-1st week, using the 'sd' dehumidifier in the dry box, with my camera &
-5th week, using the 'sd' dehumidifier in ziplock bag (with my camera too)...
-both are in the same cabinet. each experiment lasts 4 weeks.
both readings came out at that RH% i mentioned...
but its just a testing i did, just in case i have to travel, & cannot simply lug my dry cabinet along wherever i go.

Refreshing systematic testing :thumbsup: seems the bags of dehumidifier are of the right size for the small volume of air.
Personally, I don't drag any dehumidifying stuffs around when traveling. Traveling is the opposite of storing, plenty of fresh air and sun, no need for anything related to long term storage.
 

You certainly did a good comparison. Thanks

OK, I am now trying this and see the result too. Then I can figure out adjustment in my tupperware. :)

- 2 layers of Raynolds ziplock (non deflate, leave air inside).
- 1 sachet Fairprice Jumbo dehumidifier.
- 1x videocam pouch and videocam that has been in open for 1 week (forgotten to keep).
- 1 hygrometer inside, wire probe located to the pouch and vcam end.

i did an experiment using digital hygrometer ...

-1st week, using the 'sd' dehumidifier in the dry box, with my camera &
-5th week, using the 'sd' dehumidifier in ziplock bag (with my camera too)...
-both are in the same cabinet. each experiment lasts 4 weeks.

both readings came out at that RH% i mentioned...

but its just a testing i did, just in case i have to travel, & cannot simply lug my dry cabinet along wherever i go.
 

Refreshing systematic testing :thumbsup: seems the bags of dehumidifier are of the right size for the small volume of air.
Personally, I don't drag any dehumidifying stuffs around when traveling. Traveling is the opposite of storing, plenty of fresh air and sun, no need for anything related to long term storage.

oh, i just worried that if i go traveling during winter or in some remote places like acheh or afhganistan...
 

You certainly did a good comparison. Thanks

OK, I am now trying this and see the result too. Then I can figure out adjustment in my tupperware. :)

- 2 layers of Raynolds ziplock (non deflate, leave air inside).
- 1 sachet Fairprice Jumbo dehumidifier.
- 1x videocam pouch and videocam that has been in open for 1 week (forgotten to keep).
- 1 hygrometer inside, wire probe located to the pouch and vcam end.


i feel that the those box dehumidifier can be too much for a small space...i think sachet may be a better option.
 

oh, i just worried that if i go traveling during winter or in some remote places like acheh or afhganistan...

Check the climate statistics for that location. Afghanistan is a bit bigger than SG, please specify further. But still, better get good camera bag, don't waste time with silica gel or other stuffs.
 

Traveling is the opposite of storing, plenty of fresh air and sun, no need for anything related to long term storage.


Does that mean if I shoot everyday, I don't need to get a dry cabinet or dry box? :bsmilie:
 

Just curious, if you don't mind, where you got this info from? Would it corrode metals and other stuff in normal use, or does the material have to come into direct contact with the desiccant for corrosion to occur?

Yes, thirsty hippo it will not damage material unless the liquid comes into contact.
I will always throw 1 pack of thirsty hippo in my lugguage before storing.

The dessicant in thirsty hippo is calcium chloride. It corrodes when the material in
contact with moist calcium chloride.
 

The dessicant in thirsty hippo is calcium chloride. It corrodes when the material in
contact with moist calcium chloride.

But hor, wikipedia says

Calcium Chloride is also commonly used as an additive in swimming pool water as it increases the "Calcium Hardness" value for the water. Low Calcium Hardness values in pool water cause pool water to be corrosive on equipment, pumps and metal fittings.
Wiki
 

This chloride thing.... Don't know lah.

You all go and pour the dissolved liquid from thirsty hippo to you camera and clothing and hands. Then let me know the outcome :bsmilie:

You will then notice that is not ordinary liquid, it is very soapy, slimy and does not evaporate easily.
 

Last edited:
This chloride thing.... Don't know lah.

You all go and pour the dissolved liquid from thirsty hippo to you camera and clothing and hands. Then let me know the outcome :bsmilie:

You will then notice that is not ordinary liquid, it is very soapy, slimy and does not evaporate easily.

Woah you might as well ask me to throw the camera into the swimming pool! :sticktong
 

This chloride thing.... Don't know lah.

You all go and pour the dissolved liquid from thirsty hippo to you camera and clothing and hands. Then let me know the outcome :bsmilie:

You will then notice that is not ordinary liquid, it is very soapy, slimy and does not evaporate easily.

So simply put.... don't use it for your travel drying agent. If you have a simple box that's upright and stationary... the CaCl agent base won't be a problem.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.