It was taking too long to move the items over, so for the sake of accessibility, we re-opened the forums.Why not just remove the old the Marketplace section and replace with the new section? I like the separation by brand but some of the nikon or fuji items are still left back in the old section and it might get confusing.
How about posting a reply in the Classified section?
Let's say i posted a WTS ad, and the product description is not clear enough, or made a mistake.
i would have to read and reply a lot of similar pm to clarify the mistake or lack of info, when all i need to do is to add on to my previous posting.
quite a fair bit of extra work, isn't it?
Categorisation is fine/ great but why the ban on posting into a buy/sell thread. IMHO, there are several points i would like to raise:
1. Changing the description or clarifying will now be difficult ie, as a seller, i have to repost because i forgot to mention some specification like whether a lens is AF, AFD or AFS?? Similarly, as a buyer, i cannot make a simple query without having to come OFF Clubsnap to sms, e-mail. This, as a consumer is a barrier to me wanting to buy an interesting item that i may not know a lot about but now cannot easily find out.
3. Believe it or not, the once-a-day upzzz rule brought a good balance to the marketplace. Like many others, we are not at our computers 24/7. The "upzzzing" actually helps by placing the "actives" in front. Often, a thread that is not upped means that the item has been sold. Expecting every Cser to close threads diligently is naive (even though i try my best to do so...)
4. I actually feel that the life of the marketplace has disappeared overnight. I am by far a more frequent buyer than seller and without comments/ upzzz/ encouraging posts etc, we have returned to a sterility that kills the spirit of the place.
I think you did a great job of not allowing other CS member to post a reply to certain threads, because it keeps the thread clean and short. BUT by not allowing the creator of the specific threads to update his/her threads is a BIG NO. Anyhow the creator has to update his/her threads to show or remind to other CS member that it is still active or otherwise.
threads cant be replied back to...is it intended to be like this?
To be honest, the Buy & Sell section is not the most appropriate place to share information about equipment - those discussions are best placed in the respective equipment discussion sections.2. Valuable comments from fellow CSers are lost, and with it the sense of a community. How often have i stopped to read CHIFF's comments about a older lens/ camera or an interesting rangefinder that i know very little about. It is this community spirit that attracted us to clubsnap in the first place. Otherwise, it is too similar to ebay or other classifieds.
5. Clubsnap is a community, not a newspaper. The ability to share is what enabled the on-line marketplace.
We will look into the granularity of the Others section and see if there is enough "demand" to warrant a further breakdown. Thanks.Only Japanese brands represeted...?
The first five I think are fair intuitive... but from "other camera brands" onwards I think it is too vague.
Can I suggest as follows:
6) Buy/Sell: Leica, Zeiss, Voigtlander and other camera brands including Rangefinders
7) Buy/sell: All other formats except (i) FF DSLR (ii) APSC DSLR (ii) 35mm film format
If we follow the principal that ads are placed to attracting a certain group... then Nikon should be revamped to say "Nikon (& Fuji DSLR)"
How is it confusing, compared to the previous layout/sections? Please clarify so that we can improve (if possible).very confusing!!