I am sure you can figure that out for yourself if you have read those threads.
The purpose of CS is to create a friendly environment for photographers to share their work, experience and knowledge so that we all can learn from each other. To maintain the spirit the admins and mods do not tolerate posts that are targeting for personal attacks or redicule.
A post like yours here is one of the main reasons threads were closed. It is not constructive...actually pointless, and it appears to me like the main purpose is to make fun of another member.
As such, I am closing this thread before it gets "scandelous".