I'm not a big fan of the square crop and the general "tightness" of your composition. No space to fit in the reflections, which spoils the composition, in my opinion.
Your #2 has perspective distortion problem. Buildings slanting towards the center. Horizon also doesn't look horizontal.
#3 not quite suitable as a silhouette-style. Too much black mess at the bottom.
I'm not a big fan of the square crop and the general "tightness" of your composition. No space to fit in the reflections, which spoils the composition, in my opinion.
Your #2 has perspective distortion problem. Buildings slanting towards the center. Horizon also doesn't look horizontal.
#3 not quite suitable as a silhouette-style. Too much black mess at the bottom.
Thanks for the cool comments. I do think that you are right. I didn't do any cropping, as that was the 6x6 frame of my yashica mat. But I do understand where you are coming from.
#2, I should have ran this through pp to correct them.
As for the #3, thanks for pointing out the black mess. Good point to note.
Thanks!!!
@ rgborj
These were taken in March, which explains why there were still many bright construction lights.
anyway, regarding silhouettes, I think THIS is quite a good example. Though there is also some black 'mess' at the bottom, but the silhouettes are clearly defined and strong elements in the photo.
anyway, regarding silhouettes, I think THIS is quite a good example. Though there is also some black 'mess' at the bottom, but the silhouettes are clearly defined and strong elements in the photo.