Newbie Question : Which focal length for Macro?


Status
Not open for further replies.

icarus

Senior Member
Jan 27, 2002
3,874
0
0
East
#1
I am torn between a marco lens of 105mm and 150mm. Price is the same, which one should i get? What are the differences between 105 and 150? Which is better for macro?
Please give me your constructive comments, thanks! Me newbie.
 

Mar 18, 2005
284
0
0
43
#3
alucard said:
I see that your wishlist has been updated. :)

So, got the 5D? :think:

go with the 150 if you are getting at the same price. Is it the Sigma one?

Should be the sigma one he is talking about:)
 

icarus

Senior Member
Jan 27, 2002
3,874
0
0
East
#4
ALot of people say get 105, but personally 105 is too short for insects
What do u guys think?
 

blurblock

Senior Member
May 30, 2003
3,827
0
0
ytphoto.clubsnap.org
#5
icarus said:
ALot of people say get 105, but personally 105 is too short for insects
What do u guys think?
If you are taking living creature, a longer lens will be good, but then you will have to know so is the shake. If you are taking still object, then a shorter lens might be better.
 

ortega

Moderator
Staff member
Nov 2, 2004
23,694
10
38
Singapore, Singapore, Singapor
#6
almost 95% say 105mm, and you still need to ask.
come out and try it for yourself.

Punggol have lots of subjects waiting for you
 

megaweb

Moderator
Staff member
Jan 17, 2002
8,541
3
38
East
megaweb.clubsnap.org
#8
icarus said:
I am torn between a marco lens of 105mm and 150mm. Price is the same, which one should i get? What are the differences between 105 and 150? Which is better for macro?
Please give me your constructive comments, thanks! Me newbie.
150mm over 105mm
- narrow background coverage, thus less distracting background
- long focusing distance
- heavy and more stable but need support like tripod

105mm over 150mm
- slightly cheaper
- lighter and portable, thus flexibility in composition while taking handheld

which one is better ? is all depend on you ...
 

icarus

Senior Member
Jan 27, 2002
3,874
0
0
East
#9
megaweb said:
150mm over 105mm
- narrow background coverage, thus less distracting background
- long focusing distance
- heavy and more stable but need support like tripod

105mm over 150mm
- slightly cheaper
- lighter and portable, thus flexibility in composition while taking handheld

which one is better ? is all depend on you ...
Can 105 + the right extention tubes give me the same DOF/working distance as 150mm?
 

eawtan

Senior Member
Feb 4, 2004
1,370
0
36
Tampines
#10
icarus said:
Can 105 + the right extention tubes give me the same DOF/working distance as 150mm?
Ext tube will get you closer focusing (increased magnification), but will not improve working distance.
TCs 1.4x or 2x will get you better working distance (for the same magnification without TCs). :sweat:
 

icarus

Senior Member
Jan 27, 2002
3,874
0
0
East
#11
Can the Nikon 105 be fitted with any TCs?
:think:
 

Aug 4, 2005
888
3
0
#14
Haven't had experience with closeup filters but many would advise against it, saying the quality of the output isn't that good.

I've used the 105mm micro-Nikkor with a teleplus 2X TC and it works great. It doesn't shorten your working distance (in fact, you get 2X working distance IIRC) and you have 2:1 magnification. And losing 2 stops of light. If you're shooting wide open, the results may not be desirable, though. However, you'll probably be stopping down for the required DOF, so not much issue i guess.

Just my 2 cents worth ah... :bsmilie:
 

icarus

Senior Member
Jan 27, 2002
3,874
0
0
East
#16
Del_CtrlnoAlt said:
get a 300mm f2.8 & a long series of extension tubes... best of the best liao...
hard to handhold the 300/2.8 la
:sweat: :sweat: :sweat:
 

Del_CtrlnoAlt

Senior Member
Feb 15, 2003
16,268
0
0
Outside the Dry Box.
Visit site
#17
icarus said:
hard to handhold the 300/2.8 la
:sweat: :sweat: :sweat:
u did say handhold mah... but the truth is... even 90mm or 100mm handhold macro wide open also very hard... the DOF & focusing distance just slight move also can offset alot...
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom