ND & CPL filters - which ones?


Status
Not open for further replies.

electron

New Member
Jan 11, 2008
577
0
0
#1
I'm going to Japan and want to get both a ND & Circular Polarising Filter to shoot outdoors. Any brand to recommend? Is it better/cheaper to get in Japan?
 

electron

New Member
Jan 11, 2008
577
0
0
#2
I know Hoya makes these but any other brands to recommend?
 

giantcanopy

Senior Member
Feb 11, 2007
6,232
2
0
SG
#3
I know Hoya makes these but any other brands to recommend?
Many others. B+W, Cokin, Singh Ray, Lee, Hitech, Nikon ..

They are actually very easy to get off singapore shops. Why not get them locally and have a feel of how to use them before going to japan and figure them when u are shooting on the go.

I cannot think of any reason why I would want to go there to Japan to buy any particular japanese brand for now. Not sure if they sell the other higher end filters at a cheaper price :think:

Ryan
 

Zichar

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2008
2,079
10
0
#4
Probably have a tougher time getting Hoya over in Japan. Kenkos are sold there more commonly (same parent company).
I second Ryan's suggestion on getting a feel of it first here, you may not like how it turns, the thickness, how it looks, how it rests on the front of your lens, etc; who knows.
 

electron

New Member
Jan 11, 2008
577
0
0
#5
Got a Sunpack Polarising lens from Hong Kong 2 days ago only to find out it's NOT a Circular Polarising one! It was my own fault for not making sure the guy gave me a C-PL even tho I did ask for the circular version. Lesson learnt the hard way. So, I guess it's pretty much useless on my Canon 450d ?
 

giantcanopy

Senior Member
Feb 11, 2007
6,232
2
0
SG
#6
Got a Sunpack Polarising lens from Hong Kong 2 days ago only to find out it's NOT a Circular Polarising one! It was my own fault for not making sure the guy gave me a C-PL even tho I did ask for the circular version. Lesson learnt the hard way. So, I guess it's pretty much useless on my Canon 450d ?
Must be a rude shock for you :eek:

Thats why I prefer to get things I am familiar with from reputable sellers especially if online. So what did this *Sunpack Polarising lens* turn out to be? From google keyword search it seemed like it is a circular polariser.

Ryan
 

electron

New Member
Jan 11, 2008
577
0
0
#7
Must be a rude shock for you :eek:

Thats why I prefer to get things I am familiar with from reputable sellers especially if online. So what did this *Sunpack Polarising lens* turn out to be? From google keyword search it seemed like it is a circular polariser.

Ryan
Sorry Typo! I meant "Sunpack Polarising Filter" not lens. So I googled it just now and not only did i get the wrong type of filter, it seems Sunpack are not a recommended brand for filters at all! Double mistake :angry:

And yes, it was a rude shock when i got back home to discover my error. The guy in the shop was rude too. Hong Kong Style. Never intended to buy anything really but he seemed like scolding while explaining! Bit of a culture shock as I was just in Japan the where everyone was so polite the day before.

My question is - if i use this Linear Polarising Filter on my autofocus TTL metering 450D, what will happen?
 

giantcanopy

Senior Member
Feb 11, 2007
6,232
2
0
SG
#8
Sorry Typo! I meant%
Your AF might not work. Even if your AF works, the split beam is also used for the metering sensor and can be inaccurate. The linearly polarised light entering TTL can *blind* the beam splitters and semi silver mirrors in the camera and defunct the AF and metering.

Although there are claims here and there on other forums stating that theirs can work somehow with certain linear polarisers, my advise is still to get the circular ones.

Ryan
 

electron

New Member
Jan 11, 2008
577
0
0
#9
Your AF might not work. Even if your AF works, the split beam is also used for the metering sensor and can be inaccurate.

Although there are claims here and there on other forums stating that theirs can work somehow with certain linear polarisers, my advise is still to get the circular ones.

Ryan
Thanks Ryan, at least I know it won't mess up anything inside my camera. Btw, what brand CPL do you use (if you have one)? And how much do they normally cost? I got the Sunpack for $55.
 

giantcanopy

Senior Member
Feb 11, 2007
6,232
2
0
SG
#10
Thanks Ryan, at least I know it won't mess up anything inside my camera. Btw, what brand CPL do you use (if you have one)? And how much do they normally cost? I got the Sunpack for $55.
I got a Nikon Slim CPL II for the 77mm end, and a B+W Fpro MRC for the 52mm end. Any other lens diameters in between I use step up rings to the 77mm.
 

electron

New Member
Jan 11, 2008
577
0
0
#11
I got a Nikon Slim CPL II for the 77mm end, and a B+W Fpro MRC for the 52mm end. Any other lens diameters in between I use step up rings to the 77mm.
I just visited your photoblog. May I commend you on your awe inspiring shots! Also, detailing your settings for all to see is a great learning tool and would benefit many. Thanks for the tips.

I think I'm gonna go and get Singh Ray Soft Step GND filters now! And steel myself for ungodly waking hours! :)

Ben
 

giantcanopy

Senior Member
Feb 11, 2007
6,232
2
0
SG
#12
I just visited your photoblog. May I commend you on your awe inspiring shots! Also, detailing your settings for all to see is a great learning tool and would benefit many. Thanks for the tips.

I think I'm gonna go and get Singh Ray Soft Step GND filters now! And steel myself for ungodly waking hours! :)

Ben

Still adding stuffs. Glad you like them.
Anything can pm me and see what i can do to help

Ryan
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom