Can i charge SANYO eveloop batteries on other brand chargers


Status
Not open for further replies.

cytan

New Member
Jun 4, 2008
141
0
0
Bendemeer
#1
Hi guys,

Like to check with you all have anyone charged sanyo eneloop batteries on other brand of chargers ?

Cos heard that its will be best to charge the battery using the original brand charger otherwise, the lifespan of the battery will be reduced greatly..

Hope to verify this with you guys "p

Thanks for the advice
 

night86mare

Deregistered
Aug 25, 2006
25,541
0
0
www.pbase.com
#2
hello

so long as it is a good charger, that is only true to a very limited extent. the original charger would provide the best fit, of course, but with a good charger, anything goes. don't worry too much about it unless your charger is hello kitty brand.

no problems, so long as your charger is for charging rechargeable batteries.
 

boyboy

New Member
Oct 15, 2007
561
0
0
#3
if u are using a decent brand charger (to me, sony and maha are among the "decent" brands, GP is lousy IMHO), it can be just as good.

just don't use some unknown china *brand* charger (don't confuse with china-made, cos many branded stuff made in china). more importantly, unless u need ur batteries charged in a flash, try to go for those which charge at a slower rate, or offer u the option to do a slow charge.

the speed of the charging (and hence the temperature ur batteries are subject to) is the factor which really determines how many cycles ur battery can last
 

lennyl

New Member
Mar 27, 2008
1,520
0
0
Northern California
#4
Like to check with you all have anyone charged sanyo eneloop batteries on other brand of chargers ?
I'm not sure how good is the quality of the Sanyo charger in the first place.

I've been charging my Eneloops on my old faithful Maha MH-C204F (approaching 10 years old now) without any problems.

NiMH chargers come in a few varieties. The dumbest of the lot only comes with a timer circuit, and charges all batteries for the same time. Avoid them like the plague. I have an Energizer brand charger that works like that.

The best chargers would be able to charge each battery individually (my C204F unfortunately charges in pairs only). They monitor the charge level of each battery and switches to trickle when it is close to maximum capacity.

Rapid charging is bad for the health of the battery, but is preferable to having dead batteries IMHO. Use them when you need them, but try to plan ahead so that you don't.
 

nakedtoes

Deregistered
Jan 12, 2004
577
0
0
#8
Just get the fastest charger u can get.. now rechargable batterries is so cheap whos care about the slight drop in lifespan or charge cycle..
 

lennyl

New Member
Mar 27, 2008
1,520
0
0
Northern California
#9
Just get the fastest charger u can get.. now rechargable batterries is so cheap whos care about the slight drop in lifespan or charge cycle..
Rapid chargers will not recharge to the maximum capacity as well. Something you may want to keep in mind. Some rapid chargers will switch to trickle mode once it is close to full charge, but you'd still need to leave the batteries in it for a couple of hours to bring it up to maximum charge.
 

twnll

New Member
Mar 23, 2008
215
0
0
North
#10
Can advise what chargers to get to get optimal charge and charge cycles? I dun mind buying a good charger for $100 if it can last a long time and give good performance. How's the charger sold by EastGear?
 

cytan

New Member
Jun 4, 2008
141
0
0
Bendemeer
#11
Thanks alot fellas

Think i can save up on the charger "p and get something else
 

nakedtoes

Deregistered
Jan 12, 2004
577
0
0
#12
Rapid chargers will not recharge to the maximum capacity as well. Something you may want to keep in mind. Some rapid chargers will switch to trickle mode once it is close to full charge, but you'd still need to leave the batteries in it for a couple of hours to bring it up to maximum charge.
yea i know about this.. but most rapid charger are smart enough to charge as full as possible and employing tickle charge to maintain the batteries at optimum charge. I have used so many chargers that i can tell u to get the 15 mins charger the sanyo one that has a fan in it.. it is as good as those 1hr or 2hr charger. The issue with shorter and less optimum charge is heat... even the maha 1 hr charger 204 charging performance is worse then any sanyo chargers in the market now...the heat is scary.. touch it while u charge for 30 mins u will know.. u touch the sanyo 15mins charger the battery is still cool;)
 

adiknaim

New Member
Feb 9, 2008
440
0
0
Choa Chu Kang
#13
i using GP 6hr charger to charge my Sonys and Eneloops.. good charge so far. no probs. so can say GP charger ok la. cant say the same for their batts though..
 

Legoz

New Member
Mar 7, 2008
1,003
0
0
#14
Actually, Guys can advise me on why the GP batteries are no good?
I've seen the comments a number of times in the forum but i've used them for the longest time and they seem fine.
Hahaha...i dont wanna get caught out one day.. =p
 

Oct 18, 2006
276
0
0
Singapore
#15
Actually, Guys can advise me on why the GP batteries are no good?
I've seen the comments a number of times in the forum but i've used them for the longest time and they seem fine.
Hahaha...i dont wanna get caught out one day.. =p
I previously used GP rechargeables, from AA, AAA to 9V, even the rare C and D types. They did not last anything longer than 6 months before exhibiting substantial drop in capacity. The most ridiculous was the 9V batteries when the snap in tabs SNAPPED OFF. This ends the life of the battery. But being curious, I broke open the casing to reveal corrosion within the battery. It seems that some out-gassing as occured and corroded the battery from inside. Imagine this battery doing that to the inside of your camera grip or flash. I am not going to risk that.

My take is that cheap equals compromise, expensive is not necessarily good. You must use to conclude.
 

cichlid

Senior Member
Dec 2, 2006
5,073
3
38
S'pore
#16
I'm not sure how good is the quality of the Sanyo charger in the first place.

I've been charging my Eneloops on my old faithful Maha MH-C204F (approaching 10 years old now) without any problems.

NiMH chargers come in a few varieties. The dumbest of the lot only comes with a timer circuit, and charges all batteries for the same time. Avoid them like the plague. I have an Energizer brand charger that works like that.

The best chargers would be able to charge each battery individually (my C204F unfortunately charges in pairs only). They monitor the charge level of each battery and switches to trickle when it is close to maximum capacity.

Rapid charging is bad for the health of the battery, but is preferable to having dead batteries IMHO. Use them when you need them, but try to plan ahead so that you don't.
What are the chargers that can charge the batt individually? Roughly how much?
 

Legoz

New Member
Mar 7, 2008
1,003
0
0
#17
I previously used GP rechargeables, from AA, AAA to 9V, even the rare C and D types. They did not last anything longer than 6 months before exhibiting substantial drop in capacity. The most ridiculous was the 9V batteries when the snap in tabs SNAPPED OFF. This ends the life of the battery. But being curious, I broke open the casing to reveal corrosion within the battery. It seems that some out-gassing as occured and corroded the battery from inside. Imagine this battery doing that to the inside of your camera grip or flash. I am not going to risk that.

My take is that cheap equals compromise, expensive is not necessarily good. You must use to conclude.

Alrite...thanks!
which really means that my GP batteries are due for replacement soon.
My only prob with them is that after like 2 years or so, they tend to be unable to charge anymore. And to me, that signals the end of the battery cycle.

But of course, 2 years to me...is acceptable.

I never move on to any other brands because my charger was from GP. Sooo i always stick with their batts. Now that i know any charger can be used for any other batts...perhapes, its time i change. =)

Regards
 

lennyl

New Member
Mar 27, 2008
1,520
0
0
Northern California
#18
What are the chargers that can charge the batt individually? Roughly how much?
Only know of two off the top of my head (I'm sure there are many others if you do some research). Maha MH-C9000 (US$60) and LaCrosse BC-900 (US$40). Not sure what they go for in Singapore. Both are a little on the overkill side, with LCD to tell you all you don't need to know about your batteries, and the ability to "recondition" the batteries.

Edit : looks like the MH-C401FS charges each cell independently as well.
 

noob117

New Member
Oct 16, 2006
1,313
0
0
west
#19
I previously used GP rechargeables, from AA, AAA to 9V, even the rare C and D types. They did not last anything longer than 6 months before exhibiting substantial drop in capacity. The most ridiculous was the 9V batteries when the snap in tabs SNAPPED OFF. This ends the life of the battery. But being curious, I broke open the casing to reveal corrosion within the battery. It seems that some out-gassing as occured and corroded the battery from inside. Imagine this battery doing that to the inside of your camera grip or flash. I am not going to risk that.

My take is that cheap equals compromise, expensive is not necessarily good. You must use to conclude.

thats true,for my AA 2100mah GPs.

but ReCyko+s are good, seems to last forever!
 

zac08

Senior Member
Feb 21, 2005
11,755
0
0
East
#20
Just make sure the charger does not send too much current to the batteries.

Quick chargers tend to do this.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom