Which Ultra-wide angle lenses is better?


Status
Not open for further replies.

wizzard

New Member
May 29, 2009
47
0
0
#1
Think of getting a ultra-wide angle zoom lenses for canon mount.
As i am sure alot of bro/sis out there has experimented ultra-wide lenses with splendid result, any recommendation will be of great help to me in terms of performance/result/value for $$......

Google a few as below:
1) Tokina - http://www.tokinalens.com/products/tokina/atx116prodx-a.html
2) Sigma - http://www.sigmaphoto.com/lenses/lenses_all_details.asp?id=3236&navigator=1
3) Tamron - http://www.tamron.com/lenses/prod/1024_diII.asp
4) Canon - http://www.canon.com/camera-museum/camera/lens/ef/data/ef-s/ef_s10~22_35~45_usm.html

Hope to get some feedbacks/pointers from fellow CSer...:D
Thks in advance
 

Last edited:

Snoweagle

Senior Member
Jan 26, 2005
14,002
0
0
Pasir Ris, Singapore
#3
For crop, EF-S 10-22, sigma's 10-20, tamron's 10-24 and tokina's 12-24 or 11-16.

For FF, 17-40, 16-35 or sigma's 12-24. If u want prime, can consider 14mm.
 

Rashkae

Senior Member
Nov 28, 2005
19,105
12
0
#4
I'm using Singma's 12-24 on a FF body. It's not as sharp as the CZ 16-35, but 12mm is awesome. It's sharp enough once you stop it down to F8 or so, and the slight "Sigmaish" yellow tint is easily corrected.
 

Reim1o

New Member
Jun 14, 2008
180
0
0
Melbourne, Australia
redbubble.com
#5
I think I'm qualified to comment since I've tried sigma 10-20, tamron 10-24, and sigma 12-24 at the stores, and owned canon 10-22, tokina 11-16, tokina 12-24.

If you want simple answer, Tokina 11-16 is the best in terms of sharpness (by small margin to all other lenses). Sigma 12-24mm best in distortion control, and canon 10-22 in colour & contrast.
 

Aug 8, 2008
605
0
0
Singapore
#6
I think I'm qualified to comment since I've tried sigma 10-20, tamron 10-24, and sigma 12-24 at the stores, and owned canon 10-22, tokina 11-16, tokina 12-24.

If you want simple answer, Tokina 11-16 is the best in terms of sharpness (by small margin to all other lenses). Sigma 12-24mm best in distortion control, and canon 10-22 in colour & contrast.
Wow. Thanks for the info. I've got Canon EFS10-22, and have always been wondering how it stacks up against the rest. You're right about the Canon's colour/constrast. It not so good with sharpness at the fringes.
 

wizzard

New Member
May 29, 2009
47
0
0
#7
I am using a CF.

Wow thks for all the valuable information.
guess those lenses have their pros & cons,
now i can narrow it down to either canon's or tokina's
:cool:
 

Shin Howard

Senior Member
Feb 18, 2008
1,063
0
36
North Eastern Region
#8
The sharpness of the Tokina 11-16 is excellent @ wide open aperture.
But most of the time you wouldn't use it @ f/2.8.
So you shd maybe consider the Canon 10-22.
 

2evans

New Member
Nov 8, 2007
1,862
0
0
#9
I've had really great experience using canon's 10-22. Like other have said, the colours and contrast are really good.
 

Blur Shadow

Senior Member
Sep 17, 2005
4,886
4
0
#11
No fiscal concerns? Go for the Canon 10-22mm. I liked it. Else, competition is very keen. You really should try things out to see what you like.
 

night86mare

Deregistered
Aug 25, 2006
25,541
0
0
www.pbase.com
#13
most uwa , third party or original are pretty good.

some considerations you should take note of:

1) perspective, 10mm and 12mm very big difference for me.

2) type of distortion, some can be corrected easier than others. for example, sigma 10-20 is excellent, but distortion is very weird at 10mm, to correct properly you need dxo plugin correction, or use liquify

3) whether can use filters, because of filter thread being present or not

4) widest aperture (frankly, not important, landscapes should be f/8 and above - if you are going to shoot handheld, then i question your interest in landscapes.. and if you use uwa for anything else, it is not really going to be a serious picture most of the time)
 

wizzard

New Member
May 29, 2009
47
0
0
#14
Really appreciate all the generous feedback, i guess i really have to go down to MS to try out the 2 lenses and get a feel of the real stuff.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom