It's supposingly the same compostition (but slightly off coz i had to reframe it as it's spot focusing) but different focal point. anyway, which one works for you?
To be honest, i don't like either. Firstly because it is not very intuitive that it is a "chocolate cake" of some sort. Yes, food photography don't always need to capture the whole dish itself, but in this case it would be better if we can see the sides of the cake to have some "volume" to the product. I like the lighting though.