UV filter VS CPL


Status
Not open for further replies.

Nikonguy

New Member
Jul 4, 2008
34
0
0
#1
Dear all,

Are there any disadvantages using CPL over UV filters besides pricing and vignetting issue?

Thanks all
 

tunge

New Member
Mar 15, 2009
502
0
0
38
#3
Dear all,

Are there any disadvantages using CPL over UV filters besides pricing and vignetting issue?

Thanks all
ur question can be interperated in 2 ways...

1st: CPL filters are not replacements for UV filters and vice versa, they are different filters and server different purposes, so answer is "NO" disavantage nor disavantage.

2nd: using CPL over UV filters, taking to mean stacking CPL on top of UV filters is generally not encouraged as it will result in vignetting esp at wider angle and pic IQ may dropped.
 

night86mare

Deregistered
Aug 25, 2006
25,541
0
0
www.pbase.com
#4
you need to read up more about photography

uv filter is usually just for protection, it isn't actually needed.

cpl is for many other things. see lordpain's link.
 

Nikonguy

New Member
Jul 4, 2008
34
0
0
#5
ok, thanks people.

Didnt know it will create such a huge difference. Confirm must get it over UV filters.:)

So let say if I never use filter( shutter speed 1/500) and after using cpl, will it become slower shutter speed?

Thanks
 

Linnl71

New Member
Jul 2, 2009
387
0
0
26
East area
#6
Not a pro, but if I'm not wrong the filter wouldn't affect shutter speed.
 

kutten

New Member
May 12, 2008
293
0
0
East
#7
ok, thanks people.

Didnt know it will create such a huge difference. Confirm must get it over UV filters.:)

So let say if I never use filter( shutter speed 1/500) and after using cpl, will it become slower shutter speed?

Thanks
Yes, subtract ~ 2 stops of light.
 

Octarine

Moderator
Staff member
Jan 3, 2008
12,518
32
48
Pasir Ris
#8
Didnt know it will create such a huge difference. Confirm must get it over UV filters.:)
Didn't they all say "Don't stack"? or what do you mean with "must get over UV"?

So let say if I never use filter( shutter speed 1/500) and after using cpl, will it become slower shutter speed?
No such generic answer. To be precise: the amount of light is reduced, hence the exposure will be -1EV or up to -2EV if not corrected by other means. Depending on the Program Mode of your camera either the aperture is opened as correction (in Shutter Priority Mode) or the shutter speed is lowered (in Aperture Priority Mode). Manual will only show the lower resulting exposure level.
 

Nikonguy

New Member
Jul 4, 2008
34
0
0
#10
Hi bro, what i meant was, prefer CPL to UV and not stack, sorry for the misunderstanding.

But now must sacrifice 2 stops of light coming in.

Is it easy to use? will ppl use it wrongly for cpl?
 

tunge

New Member
Mar 15, 2009
502
0
0
38
#11
bro i think u are driving some us crazy with ur replies, cos it seems the more u reply the more confused u sound abt CPL and UV filters.

i don't understand why u should "prefer" CPL to UV when they basically serve different purposes. it's like saying u prefer a fork to a spoon.

u must first understand why u need or use a CPL filter for. so do u know what CPL does for u?

lastly as to ur qn abt whether CPL us easy to use, answer is "YES" but do people use it wrongly? answer is also "YES"

google and read up more.
 

Last edited:

Nikonguy

New Member
Jul 4, 2008
34
0
0
#12
bro i think u are driving some us crazy with ur replies, cos it seems the more u reply the more confused u sound abt CPL and UV filters.

i don't understand why u should "prefer" CPL to UV when they basically serve different purposes. it's like saying u prefer a fork to a spoon.

u must first understand why u need or use a CPL filter for. so do u know what CPL does for u?

lastly as to ur qn abt whether CPL us easy to use, answer is "YES" but do people use it wrongly? answer is also "YES"

google and read up more.
Wa, haha
Apologise if i confused... The more i read, i get even more confuse.
I understand CPL is for landscape where beautiful blue sky and green trees are captured.
It has its purpose to minimise reflections on glass and water.

Tio bo?
 

tunge

New Member
Mar 15, 2009
502
0
0
38
#13
Wa, haha
Apologise if i confused... The more i read, i get even more confuse.
I understand CPL is for landscape where beautiful blue sky and green trees are captured.
It has its purpose to minimise reflections on glass and water.

Tio bo?
haha textbook answer... u got "A" ;)

next for practical, which is to understand when in what situationa and lighting it'll be useful or useless/pointless. then u can decide if u need it on ur lens all the time or not. cos as mentioned, the CPL filter does add abt 2 stops usually, resulting in a need for slower shutter, higher ISO, which means more noise or shake/bluring.... from ur replies it sounds like u intend to have a CPL on ur lens all the time (doubling it as a lens protector)
 

kutten

New Member
May 12, 2008
293
0
0
East
#14
bro i think u are driving some us crazy with ur replies, cos it seems the more u reply the more confused u sound abt CPL and UV filters.

i don't understand why u should "prefer" CPL to UV when they basically serve different purposes. it's like saying u prefer a fork to a spoon.

u must first understand why u need or use a CPL filter for. so do u know what CPL does for u?

lastly as to ur qn abt whether CPL us easy to use, answer is "YES" but do people use it wrongly? answer is also "YES"

google and read up more.
:bsmilie::bsmilie: Cool down brother, I was wonder who will answer the last question. I think he is confused. Give him a chance :bsmilie::bsmilie:
 

Nikonguy

New Member
Jul 4, 2008
34
0
0
#15
Cool down brother, I was wonder who will answer the last question. I think he is confused. Give him a chance :bsmilie::bsmilie:
Well, by the way, no one is angry :)

Gimme chance to learn more so next time i teach people the right way.:bsmilie:

So are u using CPL as well?
 

Octarine

Moderator
Staff member
Jan 3, 2008
12,518
32
48
Pasir Ris
#17
I understand CPL is for landscape where beautiful blue sky and green trees are captured.
It has its purpose to minimise reflections on glass and water.
CPL is used when there is ample light to filter (blue sky) and reflections. In the absence of sun light (e.g. at night) there's nothing left to filter - so take it off. Filters are tools, use them when needed. Secondly, in case the resulting shutter speed is too low for handholding then you can a) increase ISO; or b) use a tripod.
 

Rashkae

Senior Member
Nov 28, 2005
19,105
12
0
#18
2 stops... wow.

Means if taking pics if low light available got to remove?
Why on earth would you use a CPL in low light conditions?

Please try to read up on when to use what filter.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom