Slot-in ND filters


CamInit

New Member
Nov 3, 2009
756
0
0
#1
Looking for slot-in ND filters above ND8 (3-stops) compatible with Cokin P-series holder. Are tian ya the only ones available here? Yes, I did search, but just in case I missed out. Can't seem to find any other brand. Cokin ones stop at ND8. OP has up to tian ya ND16 ($50). Considering to get a set of say, 2/4/8-stops.
:dunno:
 

Sep 17, 2008
3,656
0
0
#2
Looking for slot-in ND filters above ND8 (3-stops) compatible with Cokin P-series holder. Are tian ya the only ones available here? Yes, I did search, but just in case I missed out. Can't seem to find any other brand. Cokin ones stop at ND8. OP has up to tian ya ND16 ($50). Considering to get a set of say, 2/4/8-stops.
:dunno:
hmm. personally i'm using tianya. i'll just say tat quality wise its :thumbsd:
cause its very very uneven. i get black concentrated specs. just a warning to u lar.
 

daredevil123

Moderator
Staff member
Oct 25, 2005
21,645
63
48
lil red dot
#3
hmm. personally i'm using tianya. i'll just say tat quality wise its :thumbsd:
cause its very very uneven. i get black concentrated specs. just a warning to u lar.
Yup, tian ya is quite uneven at times. But they're dirt cheap.

I am using mostly Cokins. Cokin is also considered cheap range as it tends to give some red color cast when you use ND with more stops and when you stack.

If you really want good filters, you will have to buy Lee filters. And those are freaking ex.
 

giantcanopy

Senior Member
Feb 11, 2007
6,232
2
0
SG
#5
Cokin is a pretty hit and miss, i have seen people complaining about color cast, and it can be really extreme as if it is a colored filter, but the same filter can be having good reviews as well. probably the QC. For ND i guess having an even color cast, correction issin as bad as a GND with color cast.

There is a filter called Hitech that is supposedly value for money ( cheaper than Lee ) and yet better than Cokin in QC. But i I am not sure if it is carried locally, and u might have to purchase online.

ryan
 

daredevil123

Moderator
Staff member
Oct 25, 2005
21,645
63
48
lil red dot
#6
Cokin is a pretty hit and miss, i have seen people complaining about color cast, and it can be really extreme as if it is a colored filter, but the same filter can be having good reviews as well. probably the QC. For ND i guess having an even color cast, correction issin as bad as a GND with color cast.

There is a filter called Hitech that is supposedly value for money ( cheaper than Lee ) and yet better than Cokin in QC. But i I am not sure if it is carried locally, and u might have to purchase online.

ryan
Not really QC. I see it in most heavy NDs. It is evident especially when stacked, not obvious when not stacked. But nowadays, I do not stack as much. And the color cast is, to a certain extent, fixable actually.

Had looked up and down for Hitech. Cannot find in Singapore. Haizz.... But I heard Hitech can give a color cast too, just different color from Cokin.
 

Last edited:

night86mare

Deregistered
Aug 25, 2006
25,541
0
0
www.pbase.com
#8
Looking for slot-in ND filters above ND8 (3-stops) compatible with Cokin P-series holder. Are tian ya the only ones available here? Yes, I did search, but just in case I missed out. Can't seem to find any other brand. Cokin ones stop at ND8. OP has up to tian ya ND16 ($50). Considering to get a set of say, 2/4/8-stops.
:dunno:
in general, i do not know of any slot in nd filters other than custom made ones.

p series will result in risk of light leaks from the gap between the filter holder slot and the lens. trust me. if you have handheld a nd110 before (10 stops) unless you press it against the lens (which will result in unsharp images) you will have light leaks, even with 28mm (in 35mm film terms).
 

night86mare

Deregistered
Aug 25, 2006
25,541
0
0
www.pbase.com
#9
ryan, hi-tech i have not seen in singapore either.

i think you have to order.

they do custom filters also , i think. someone in FM mentioned that he had ordered a slot in nd1000 from them before.
 

Top Bottom