If you feel offended you could ask why you feel like that. Because from my side there wasn't any offense meant.
Regarding topic: look at your first posting and analyze what exactly have you asked for? Very blur, very broad, unspecified. Comments about what? Something liem "yeah, works nice" or "too heavy for me"?
Nothing beats neutral reviews from the usual review sites, imho. User feedback is biased by plenty of side factors (experience, expectations, comparisons to other lenses that you don't have / know about) which makes it quite unreliable to me. Good example is the Tamron 17-50 lens. You can read reviews to get the real details. or you can read user complaints about noise AF motor, focusing problems and other stuff where it is obvious where the "judgement" comes from.
Specific feedback starts with a precise question.