need some advice on this tripod + ballhead combination


Jun 5, 2010
42
0
0
40
#1
planning to buy a Sirul T1004X or T1005X and probably a G10 or G20.
which ballhead would u guys recommend?

my max weight is less than 5kg
 

Last edited:

bonrya

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2010
2,632
3
38
In a mobile cage
#4
your max weight now is less than 5kg, but are you sure about this max weight not increasing in future? if you get a better one i.e. k20x you won't have the need to upgrade when your gears change around.

what are you planning to mount on your tripod?

some of the seniors here recommended that i should get a tripod that goes to at least my eye level when the centre column is not fully extended.. especially if you're shooting things like landscape. the T1004x or 1005x will be too short for you..? or not?

have you gone to the sirui website? i think the graph there is actually quite useful as a gauge..

http://www.siruiusa.com/tripods.htm

or else a simple search for tripod recommendation will show the following thread:
http://www.clubsnap.com/forums/thre...elines-on-selection-of-tripod-and-tripod-head
 

Jun 5, 2010
42
0
0
40
#5
your max weight now is less than 5kg, but are you sure about this max weight not increasing in future? if you get a better one i.e. k20x you won't have the need to upgrade when your gears change around.

what are you planning to mount on your tripod?

some of the seniors here recommended that i should get a tripod that goes to at least my eye level when the centre column is not fully extended.. especially if you're shooting things like landscape. the T1004x or 1005x will be too short for you..? or not?

have you gone to the sirui website? i think the graph there is actually quite useful as a gauge..

http://www.siruiusa.com/tripods.htm

or else a simple search for tripod recommendation will show the following thread:
http://www.clubsnap.com/forums/thre...elines-on-selection-of-tripod-and-tripod-head
my height is around 175m, dun think i will buy any long lens.
btw T1004 and T1005, which is better?
 

bonrya

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2010
2,632
3
38
In a mobile cage
#6
my height is around 175m, dun think i will buy any long lens.
btw T1004 and T1005, which is better?
if you are 175cm, do you think the tripod will be to your eye level? have a look at the table in the link given, there's not much differences between the two.

you can also go down to tk to try out the tripods to see if they are suitable for you. the people there don't mind people molesting their display sets. ;)
 

daredevil123

Moderator
Staff member
Oct 25, 2005
21,660
68
48
lil red dot
#7
my height is around 175m, dun think i will buy any long lens.
btw T1004 and T1005, which is better?
T1005x is 5 section. T1004x is 4 section. 4 section is definitely more stable than 5 section.

T1005x folds 4cm shorter, but thinnest leg is thinner, so less stable.
T1004x's thinnest leg section is 16mm, which is quite thick for a travel tripod. Highly recommend.

Both tripod weighs the same.

I recommend the T1004x. I am selling mine in BnS, coz I upgraded. ;P
 

Jun 5, 2010
42
0
0
40
#8
T1005x is 5 section. T1004x is 4 section. 4 section is definitely more stable than 5 section.

T1005x folds 4cm shorter, but thinnest leg is thinner, so less stable.
T1004x's thinnest leg section is 16mm, which is quite thick for a travel tripod. Highly recommend.

Both tripod weighs the same.

I recommend the T1004x. I am selling mine in BnS, coz I upgraded. ;P
that is very informative and helpful.
what ballhead would u recommend? G10 or G20?

mind if i ask what tripod are u using now?
 

Cowseye

Senior Member
Mar 7, 2010
3,786
0
0
Singapore
www.ttlo-cowseye.com
#9
daredevil123 said:
T1005x is 5 section. T1004x is 4 section. 4 section is definitely more stable than 5 section.

T1005x folds 4cm shorter, but thinnest leg is thinner, so less stable.
T1004x's thinnest leg section is 16mm, which is quite thick for a travel tripod. Highly recommend.

Both tripod weighs the same.

I recommend the T1004x. I am selling mine in BnS, coz I upgraded. ;P
To what bro? :p

The T series is more preferred than the R series becos of it's low angle capability. You might be surprise how low people goes to, to shoot landscape.
@Bonyra: have you tried shooting at very low height and angle? It gives a brand new perspective. Worth a try :)
 

spree86

Senior Member
Feb 3, 2009
4,774
0
0
Bishan
www.flickr.com
#10
dark cloud said:
that is very informative and helpful.
what ballhead would u recommend? G10 or G20?

mind if i ask what tripod are u using now?
They have newer ballheads too the K10 and K20. I wanted to used them on my tripod but decided against it. I preferred the older G10 and G20 but at that time there was no stock
 

Cowseye

Senior Member
Mar 7, 2010
3,786
0
0
Singapore
www.ttlo-cowseye.com
#11
dark cloud said:
that is very informative and helpful.
what ballhead would u recommend? G10 or G20?

mind if i ask what tripod are u using now?
I also suggest skipping the G series and go straight for the K series for ballhead. Lesser knob for lesser accidental mistwist.
 

bonrya

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2010
2,632
3
38
In a mobile cage
#13
To what bro? :p

The T series is more preferred than the R series becos of it's low angle capability. You might be surprise how low people goes to, to shoot landscape.
@Bonyra: have you tried shooting at very low height and angle? It gives a brand new perspective. Worth a try :)
hi uncle cow, yeah.. i'm using a manfrotto 190xprob, so i go as low as low can be without touching the floor. (though there are of course other tripods that can go lower, but)

the thing i was trying to highlight is that.... tripods maybe able to go low, but the max height is fixed. if it stops at 1400cm, shooting at 1700 is not possible unless you have something to prop it up against etc. :)

thanks for the tips! :D
 

symmetrix

New Member
Mar 14, 2011
387
3
0
#16
To what bro? :p

The T series is more preferred than the R series becos of it's low angle capability. You might be surprise how low people goes to, to shoot landscape.
@Bonyra: have you tried shooting at very low height and angle? It gives a brand new perspective. Worth a try :)
I should give low angles a try myself. Gives my tripod another use besides long exposures. :sweat:
 

spree86

Senior Member
Feb 3, 2009
4,774
0
0
Bishan
www.flickr.com
#17
dreamsz said:
This Quote sounds very expensive !
But it kinda makes sense, I only stopped upgrading after my 3rd tripod. Wished I had bought it earlier and save myself some money and time in the BnS
 

ZerocoolAstra

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2008
9,522
0
0
rainy Singapore
#18
my height is around 175m, dun think i will buy any long lens.
btw T1004 and T1005, which is better?

TS, if you are 175cm tall, your eye level should be about... 165cm?
Deduct:
- height from viewfinder to base of camera
- height of tripod head
and you get the (required) height of the tripod when legs are fully deployed.
If you are willing to bend a bit to look through the viewfinder, then the tripod can be a little bit shorter :)

I prefer not to get 5-section tripods unless I really need the tripod to be very short when folded.
This is your personal preference.
 

Jun 5, 2010
42
0
0
40
#19
TS, if you are 175cm tall, your eye level should be about... 165cm?
Deduct:
- height from viewfinder to base of camera
- height of tripod head
and you get the (required) height of the tripod when legs are fully deployed.
If you are willing to bend a bit to look through the viewfinder, then the tripod can be a little bit shorter :)

I prefer not to get 5-section tripods unless I really need the tripod to be very short when folded.
This is your personal preference.
bro, thanks for the sound advice.
think i'll go for T1004X, and decide which whether to get G20 or KX10.

any recommendation?
 

symmetrix

New Member
Mar 14, 2011
387
3
0
#20
But it kinda makes sense, I only stopped upgrading after my 3rd tripod. Wished I had bought it earlier and save myself some money and time in the BnS
You have a freaking Gitzo. I'll seriously doubt your sanity if you still wanna upgrade after that. :bsmilie:

bro, thanks for the sound advice.
think i'll go for T1004X, and decide which whether to get G20 or KX10.

any recommendation?
Bring your heaviest setup that you'll use for the tripod and see if it holds up. If you can't, go with the more expensive one to give yourself leeway. LOL
 

Top Bottom