My take on Video slideshows of photographs


Status
Not open for further replies.

sinlg

New Member
Jun 21, 2004
355
0
0
50
#1
Hi all,

I recently had a chance to try out two software products namely ProShow Gold and PictureShow(ULEAD).

Conclusion : ProShow is the winner hands down. Although PictureShow does cute DVD menus.

Best
Steve
 

ST_sg

New Member
Mar 23, 2004
1,654
0
0
sunnytang.zenfolio.com
#2
sinlg said:
Hi all,

I recently had a chance to try out two software products namely ProShow Gold and PictureShow(ULEAD).

Conclusion : ProShow is the winner hands down. Although PictureShow does cute DVD menus.

Best
Steve
Hi Steve,

Just wondering is the ProShow's VCD playback quality good? I did try out the MoTV, its VCD quality not so satisfactory.

Thanks :)
 

zaxh81

Senior Member
Jan 29, 2003
4,339
0
0
Earth
louisleow.blogspot.com
#3
ST_sg said:
Hi Steve,

Just wondering is the ProShow's VCD playback quality good? I did try out the MoTV, its VCD quality not so satisfactory.

Thanks :)
yes MOTV vcd quality cannot make it,try once at my sis wedding and i really regret i did not use the mpeg2 plugin to burn to DVD.
Quality could be better.
 

ST_sg

New Member
Mar 23, 2004
1,654
0
0
sunnytang.zenfolio.com
#4
zaxh81 said:
yes MOTV vcd quality cannot make it,try once at my sis wedding and i really regret i did not use the mpeg2 plugin to burn to DVD.
Quality could be better.
Yup. MoTV to DVD deliver better image quality. But I just wonder the poor image quality is due to nature of VCD format or the software.? :dunno:
 

sinlg

New Member
Jun 21, 2004
355
0
0
50
#5
ST_sg said:
Yup. MoTV to DVD deliver better image quality. But I just wonder the poor image quality is due to nature of VCD format or the software.? :dunno:
VCD format is very bad. resolution is very low. So far, I tried SVCD format using ProShow... very nice.. maybe good enough and DVD not needed.

That way, you can put more photos into one DVD (using SVCD format). Although this is out of spec, but these days DVD players plays everything.
 

Apr 22, 2002
761
0
0
Central
#6
So anyone compared the Proshow and the memories to TV? any diff? :dunno:
 

ST_sg

New Member
Mar 23, 2004
1,654
0
0
sunnytang.zenfolio.com
#7
MatthewSCL said:
So anyone compared the Proshow and the memories to TV? any diff? :dunno:
I guess, from the findings above, avoid VCD format. Go for SVCD or DVD as far as Image quality concern if for displaying photos on TV.
 

jbma

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2003
3,287
0
0
Tampines
#8
I've tried a few softwares. I find ProShow Gold to be better. However in order to get the best quality slideshow you should create DVD instead of VCD. VCD cannot make it.
 

Jer76

Senior Member
Apr 21, 2002
1,049
0
36
West
#9
Proshow :thumbsup: used it for some wedding dinner slideshow so far has not let me down.
 

sinlg

New Member
Jun 21, 2004
355
0
0
50
#10
I find ProShow Gold very good. However, it seems slugish in performance.. seems like everything you do, it loads the slides information all over again. Kind of slow. Otherwise Kudos to ProShow Gold.

I think they should add a wizard to simplify simple slideshows though. ;)
 

MatthewSCL

New Member
Apr 22, 2002
761
0
0
Central
#12
however, i tested the pro show with words and somehow, the transitions (between the words and the picture) was not played smoothly on the samsung dvd player...the rest were ok (photos to photos)....buut once u add in words...transition was not smooth...
 

wf7850

New Member
Feb 3, 2005
108
0
0
#13
Presently using Video Impression VCD format really suckssss....

Will try on Proshow Gold can i know how much is this ? Where can i get hold of one?

Thanks.
 

cosycatus

Senior Member
Jun 9, 2004
1,132
0
36
#14
to run quickly in proshow, resize ur pics to a smaller resolution. Having a few hundred 3-4 mb pictures will make for slow rendering and processing.
i generally use 800*480.

Its easy to use, but sometimes, i think a bit limited, especially with words. But overall, its ease wins hands down.

Someone recently recommend sony vegas, i haven tried it, anyone has?
 

Paladin

New Member
Jan 18, 2002
723
2
0
47
SGP
Visit site
#15
I use Liquid and finds it very easy and flexible with unlimited tracks. It is very resouce draining though as it is a full editor like Vegas
 

sinlg

New Member
Jun 21, 2004
355
0
0
50
#16
There is a new version call ProShow Producer - that supports DVD ;) yeah!
It also support layers now (the user interface to the layers are still unpolished though)
 

Jul 12, 2005
102
0
0
#17
hey i have the programme (proshow gold)but how do u do the layers? i can't get 2 pictures in a slide leh... and i read the inside help but nothing is said about the layers. can any kind soul pls help mi out thanks...
 

sinlg

New Member
Jun 21, 2004
355
0
0
50
#18
xiaowugui82 said:
hey i have the programme (proshow pro)but how do u do the layers? i can't get 2 pictures in a slide leh... and i read the inside help but nothing is said about the layers. can any kind soul pls help mi out thanks...
I'm using the trial version, so the "watermark" during playback is irritating.

you have to open the animation window.. there is an option that says copy current slide as a layer to next slide. (if your next slide has already a photo), the current photo will become anothe layer in the next slide.
 

Jul 12, 2005
102
0
0
#20
( i jus figure it out liao but i jus put it up incase ppl wanna ask) then if lets say i wanna add 2 songs... one is 1 min and another is 4min. then i onli wan the first 4 slides out of 10 to syn with the first song how to do.? when i click syn selected the whole show will automatic fit into 5min. but i jus wan the first 4 to syn with the first 1min song while the rest to syn with the second 4min song. really thank for your help.

ans... have to go to the top option audio and click syn selected pictures to track. thanks...
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom