Still there is no expanation how a modern warship-frigate can hit a harmless fishing boat ? Anyone care to explain ?
The Japanese might have mistaken the fishing boat as a minky whale.
Why comment on the Japanese.
Singapore had a worse incident not long ago.
In that case, it was not a small and hard to see boat.
It was a giant tanker.
My friend who was an officer in the Navy during NS days long ago, told me there was no BASIC seamanship displayed by the lady put in charge of the navy boat.
When two vessels realise that they directly approach each other in open sea, they both turn to their respective right hand side to avoid collision.
no collision????? There were I think 7 people dead in that collision with a hard to miss tanker, a big tanker can't just move aside like a small ship can (like the fregat).......Why is it worse? There was no collision right, since both turned to starboard.
Why comment on the Japanese.
Singapore had a worse incident not long ago.
In that case, it was not a small and hard to see boat.
It was a giant tanker.
My friend who was an officer in the Navy during NS days long ago, told me there was no BASIC seamanship displayed by the lady put in charge of the navy boat.
When two vessels realise that they directly approach each other in open sea, they both turn to their respective right hand side to avoid collision.
2. Please, the underlined portion of the text is not fair to the destroyer. A small boat can see a big ship much earlier than a big ship can see a small boat. And in fact, if it's very small (Zeus size, etc) it can hide in the radar clutter and may totally evade visual detection esp in the dark, which is why captains are always afraid of terrorists packing explosives in such boats.
why cannot comment on Jap?
well, if you are refering to a normal destroyer, I guess that I could give some benefit of the doubt. but something so state of the art, I would hv expect better ...
like it or not, radar is used for keeping ALL sorts of vessels in the sea. Sing Coast Guard uses radar to detect sampans with low profiles so as to deter illegal immigrants. Something so state-of-the-art ought to do better than that.
If 12 mins were not enough time for a destroyer to stop, then the watch-keeping and detection ought to be better than tt, instead of leaving it to the autopilot.
4. 12 mins is enough time to do a lot of things. But I wonder whether the OOW was awaiting the captain's instructions before acting.
They have already ordered Canon to stop sending Canon 1 DS mk 3 to Singapore, no where to be found in local shops.........They are our biggest suppliers of cameras and lenses.
Skali offended they stop exporting them to Singapore. Si Liao!
Huh?
A military man waiting for orders on what to do for 12 minutes when the ship is on collision course?