Hmm, the composition a bit too many things to see for #2 in my view
oh ok thks...
so no isolation of center of interest.
some one told me it was all grey stuff no contrast thus boring.
so i guess bad colour and composition so its no gd
at first glance, #1 is my fav but my eyes wander around.
i can't really find a spot that draw me in.
I guess there's a certain amount of rescue work you can do with #2. You can work on the contrast, but it still lacks a main subject of interest.