"Good photos" can be bad photos.. :(


kiddyduck

New Member
Feb 24, 2010
73
0
0
#1
I was showing presenting some of my well taken macro photos on flowers and animals to a photography class. I was rather surprised with the comments my teacher and other classmates gave...

The photos I showed were close-ups on flowers and rare captures of animals which I think they made a great series... The comments I got is "It's not just about good photography skills, its more about the feelings and what you trying to express here..", another comment: "Good and precised equipment isn't the way photography goes..."

I was thinking that nature photography is to show how amazing Nature is and being able to view them up close with fine details...

Maybe thats because its a course offered by the Arts faculty and the students, teachers are more "right brained" and inclined to the artistic point of view... rather than the engineering students like to talk about the lens, the settings that made these photos, which is more focused on precision and optimization.

Just wanna hear from fellow photographers on how to make nature photography with an artistic feel... How do we composed things such as plants and animals in a way that show feelings... As what I believe, these photos are hard to come by and if it comes by but its not in a series... That may explain why nature photo series and documentaries take years to complete... and its quite disappointing when some can not appreciate the nature photos this way... and I got very discouraged by their ideas and thinking..

#1


#2


#3


#4


#5
 

Last edited:

Yangzw

New Member
Feb 21, 2009
259
0
0
#3
I'm looking forward to see TS's pictures.:)
 

pokiemon

Senior Member
Mar 5, 2005
2,039
0
0
#4
flowers have feelings?

yes please post your pictures! meanwhile dont be discouraged by their comments.
 

shellshox

New Member
Oct 15, 2008
268
0
0
#5
Maybe its about the composition, or the abstractness of a picture that invokes certain feelings to the viewer, not just a 'cool!' response. Just look at paintings and stuff, maybe you might get an idea. Remember, if its an arts class, the teachers are used to seeing certain pictures beyond the superficialities, they want more depth, more thought, more idea, more originality.... sorry quite cheem here, heh...
 

Yangzw

New Member
Feb 21, 2009
259
0
0
#6
Maybe thats because its a course offered by the Arts faculty and the students, teachers are more "right brained" and inclined to the artistic point of view... rather than the engineering students like to talk about the lens, the settings that made these photos, which is more focused on precision and optimization.
I disagree with your statement and I'm also from engineering. If its just about precision and optimization then I guess most people with right tools can produce a good pic.

Don't get discouraged. Just take others' comments with an open mind.
 

rueyloon

Senior Member
Jan 17, 2002
1,680
0
36
www.rueyloon.com
#7
I teach so I understand what you teacher may be doing.

He is keeping you in a constant state of asking questions. If he had said "Thumbs up, good work", you are probably just going to go home with a smile on your face and your learning stops there.

By asking you questions and challenging you, he is forcing you to learn.
 

catchlights

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 27, 2004
21,903
46
48
Punggol, Singapore
www.foto-u.com
#8
check out your images from your past posting,
yes, it can be technically flawless, or rare

but you don't put in your feeling when you take them,
the photos does not evoke emotion,
it does not speak the viewers,
viewers are like looking at photos of a specimen,
not a piece of art.

this is what your tutor trying to tell you.

hope this make sense to you.
 

kiddyduck

New Member
Feb 24, 2010
73
0
0
#9
Photos are up...

I guess its all about taking artistic photos or real photos... Its a totally different realm...
If you post something thats too abstract or something that is artistically blurred and you want to tell the viewer "This is a flower of xx species, rare and near extinction", it doesnt make sense ya?

For example, #4. I want to let viewers to see that glowing red tongue and the texture of the monitor lizard. The comments I got is "This is just a snapshot where you pick up a camera and shoot because you think its nice"...

Anyway, I appreciate your comments and encouragements. It didnt make my day though. But its a good experience to hear what others have said... No comments no improvements ... But its a totally unexpected moment this time round...
 

kiddyduck

New Member
Feb 24, 2010
73
0
0
#10
I disagree with your statement and I'm also from engineering. If its just about precision and optimization then I guess most people with right tools can produce a good pic.

Don't get discouraged. Just take others' comments with an open mind.
Oh yes I agree with that. The way you compose, the way you handle etc etc...
I am talking about the clarity, sharpness of the image... However, sometimes in arts, blur and noise are more sought after...
 

pokiemon

Senior Member
Mar 5, 2005
2,039
0
0
#11
Oh yes I agree with that. The way you compose, the way you handle etc etc...
I am talking about the clarity, sharpness of the image... However, sometimes in arts, blur and noise are more sought after...
these are your photos??????

they are freaking nice!!!! i love it!
 

2evans

New Member
Nov 8, 2007
1,862
0
0
#13
Photos are up...

I guess its all about taking artistic photos or real photos... Its a totally different realm...
If you post something thats too abstract or something that is artistically blurred and you want to tell the viewer "This is a flower of xx species, rare and near extinction", it doesnt make sense ya?

For example, #4. I want to let viewers to see that glowing red tongue and the texture of the monitor lizard. The comments I got is "This is just a snapshot where you pick up a camera and shoot because you think its nice"...

Anyway, I appreciate your comments and encouragements. It didnt make my day though. But its a good experience to hear what others have said... No comments no improvements ... But its a totally unexpected moment this time round...
It seems like your expectations differ from what the class has. Since it's a photography class versus say some scientific biology class, people are probably looking for an emotional attachment to them.
 

pokiemon

Senior Member
Mar 5, 2005
2,039
0
0
#14
took a third look. i like how you captured the colors, contrast and controlling the sharpness.

where did you manage to find those golden mushrooms?
 

ed9119

Moderator
Staff member
Mar 11, 2002
11,014
39
48
56
Singapore
www.walkeast.com
#17
... Its a totally different realm...
If you post something thats too abstract or something that is artistically blurred and you want to tell the viewer "This is a flower of xx species, rare and near extinction", it doesnt make sense ya?
..
well errr...... most things should not be one extreme(Arty) or the other(Scientific) ....... where does that leave middle ground ?

ahhhhh...... when you can make wood sing ......
 

Last edited:

Lolrence

Senior Member
Oct 15, 2006
1,147
0
36
#18
If you're looking at it more from a fine art perspective... I think only no. 1 is close... composition can be improved.

No. 3 looks good, but maybe it's not to their taste.

Important thing is, always know that you are working for your own portfolio... take their comments with a grain of salt.

Maybe you can start thinking of things symbolically... things don't always have to be shown right in front of you... it can be implied.
 

catchlights

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 27, 2004
21,903
46
48
Punggol, Singapore
www.foto-u.com
#19
Photos are up...

I guess its all about taking artistic photos or real photos... Its a totally different realm...
If you post something thats too abstract or something that is artistically blurred and you want to tell the viewer "This is a flower of xx species, rare and near extinction", it doesnt make sense ya?

For example, #4. I want to let viewers to see that glowing red tongue and the texture of the monitor lizard. The comments I got is "This is just a snapshot where you pick up a camera and shoot because you think its nice"...

Anyway, I appreciate your comments and encouragements. It didnt make my day though. But its a good experience to hear what others have said... No comments no improvements ... But its a totally unexpected moment this time round...
Oh yes I agree with that. The way you compose, the way you handle etc etc...
I am talking about the clarity, sharpness of the image... However, sometimes in arts, blur and noise are more sought after...
I don't think you able understand it at this point of time..

lets use an example of writing report and a poem, both are using words, both need good command of language, one describe about facts, one describe about emotion and feeling.

you are like writing reports, your tutor want you to write poem.

if you think writing poem is not you want, you should consider quit the class.
 

kiddyduck

New Member
Feb 24, 2010
73
0
0
#20
took a third look. i like how you captured the colors, contrast and controlling the sharpness.

where did you manage to find those golden mushrooms?
Those mushrooms simply popped out in one of my flower pots...

It seems like your expectations differ from what the class has. Since it's a photography class versus say some scientific biology class, people are probably looking for an emotional attachment to them.
Thats what I think too... I signed up for the class as it teaches me colour management, photography workflow, sharpening, dodging, burning, post processing... basically, technical skills... and therefore clarity, colours, medium control etc should be the focus... It's hard for me to say a blurred image is a well processed photo with artistic feel...

Thanks for your comments again.My photos are still very amateur and need improvement, I do not dare to say these are really good shots however its quite disappointing when others commented on something else that isn't my focus...
 

Top Bottom