First abstract photo post


Status
Not open for further replies.

Trapper

New Member
Sep 25, 2008
288
0
0
fr0z.multiply.com
#1
Hi fellow CSers, this is my first image posting to this subforum, hopefully the pics are not too small. All C&C are kindly appreciated!





 

gymak90

New Member
Jan 5, 2008
1,448
1
0
The Far North
#4
He did not post these in the Critique section.
True. But the TS is asking for the same thing, which is a critique. And I believe the same expectations should apply, so as to facilitate commenting and critique.

Well if I were to critique, I would say the 1st and 3rd are fine to me. The 3rd seems slightly bland. If only there could be just 1 rusty chain, it would have more impact.

The 2nd pic didn't work for me. Because I don't what is meant to be shown/portrayed by seeing a lock through a gap.
 

Jan 16, 2008
123
0
0
Singapore
#5
True. But the TS is asking for the same thing, which is a critique. And I believe the same expectations should apply, so as to facilitate commenting and critique.

Well if I were to critique, I would say the 1st and 3rd are fine to me. The 3rd seems slightly bland. If only there could be just 1 rusty chain, it would have more impact.

The 2nd pic didn't work for me. Because I don't what is meant to be shown/portrayed by seeing a lock through a gap.
Rules shmules, you've already provided a critique, and a constructive one at that. Damn amusing to always see people jumping to point out that someone hasn't 'followed the c&c rules'

:)
 

Trapper

New Member
Sep 25, 2008
288
0
0
fr0z.multiply.com
#6
True. But the TS is asking for the same thing, which is a critique. And I believe the same expectations should apply, so as to facilitate commenting and critique.

Well if I were to critique, I would say the 1st and 3rd are fine to me. The 3rd seems slightly bland. If only there could be just 1 rusty chain, it would have more impact.

The 2nd pic didn't work for me. Because I don't what is meant to be shown/portrayed by seeing a lock through a gap.
Thank for the comments bro, will take them to heart :D Didn't mean to stir up any controversy, so kindly forgive me if I have!
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom