Dry Cabinet or Dry Box?


DSolZ

New Member
Mar 6, 2010
784
6
0
#2
Hi, is there any different between a dry cabinet and a dry box?
If dry box, how often do I need to change the silica?
Suggest you to Get a dry cabinet ... Save u the need to change silica gel.
 

kklee

New Member
Aug 13, 2004
403
1
0
#5
Hi, is there any different between a dry cabinet and a dry box?
If dry box, how often do I need to change the silica?
The silica gel can be reactivated and reused.
Some may find doing that troublesome.
The alternative are those "wireless dehumidifier" which plugs into the AC socket.

How often will depend on how frequent the dry box is opened and closed.

A dry box can be quite convenient for contingency purposes e.g. when the dry cabinet is out of service. It also can be use to free up space in the dry cabinet by moving out equipment that is not used.
 

#6
I'm on budget so probably will get a dry box instead of dry cabinet.

"How often will depend on how frequent the dry box is opened and closed."
Please elaborate this sentence.

If I frequent opened, will it affect getting fungus easily?
 

coolhirako

New Member
Mar 8, 2013
1,663
7
0
Small Island
#7
Better not open frequently but best is ue your equipment frequently so there is less chance for fungus to grow

Btw bns section always have cheap 2nd hand dry cabinet selling
 

Last edited:

kklee

New Member
Aug 13, 2004
403
1
0
#8
I'm on budget so probably will get a dry box instead of dry cabinet.

"How often will depend on how frequent the dry box is opened and closed."
Please elaborate this sentence.

If I frequent opened, will it affect getting fungus easily?
Silica gel will turn from blue to pink when it absorbs water.
When the dry box is closed, the moisture from the air inside will be absorbed.
When the dry box is opened, the inside air mixes with the outside air and when closed, the cycle repeats.
This cycle will go on until the silica gel turns pink - it can no longer absorbs any moisture.

The generally accepted humidity norm to inhibit fungus growth is around 50% RH.
 

Last edited:

richiemccaw1

Senior Member
Feb 21, 2013
3,103
27
48
Singapore
#9
Looking at the effort you would need to change and/or dry silica gel, it may be wiser to spring for a dry cabinet instead. Yes a dry cabinet may cost more upfront and require constant electricity supply but it offers more convenience over the long run than a dry box.

It ultimately depends on how much you value convenience compared to others. Alternatively you may choose to go with a dry box first, and when you have more equipment or simply want a better product, then upgrade to a dry cabinet. That is perfectly fine too. I believe most people who have posted here earlier are speaking from experience.
 

Kermitfm

New Member
Mar 10, 2007
301
2
0
#10
Drybox is useful for keeping things for long term without opening regularly- example maybe once or twice a month or less regular. If you keep opening the box, the silica gel will need to be reactivated very regularly - especially in our humid climate. I don't like the hassle of recharging the silica gel. When you forget to do so the dry box becomes ineffective. I bought my dry cabinet more than 7 years ago and it is still working (fingers crossed). It's large enough to store my small collection of lens and bodies and I am convince the $ spent was worth it. Before this, my lens and accessories were all affected by fungus.

If you are thinking long term and you have spent quite a lot on your camera, then a dry cabinet is the way to go. If you just have a point and shoot, then maybe a drybox may suffice. Spending more buys you convenience and peace of mind.
 

SkyStrike

Moderator
Staff member
Nov 29, 2010
3,444
11
38
Somewhere
#11
I'm on budget so probably will get a dry box instead of dry cabinet.
A small dry box would probably cost about $35 to $50
while a small dry cabinet would cost about $100++ ($12X for digi cabi 036)


For the dry box, you will need to monitor on a regular basis to check that the humidity is within acceptable range. When the silica gel turns color (depending on how frequent you open the box, it can last 1 week or 2 week), after which you will have to change it (or do the microwave thingy which I know some people have done) then repeat this process.

For the cabinet, once I've get it into the humidity range (it will settle down within a few days), I never have to touch those knobs again.
 

catchlights

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 27, 2004
21,903
46
48
Punggol, Singapore
www.foto-u.com
#12
I'm on budget so probably will get a dry box instead of dry cabinet.

"How often will depend on how frequent the dry box is opened and closed."
Please elaborate this sentence.

If I frequent opened, will it affect getting fungus easily?
a used dry cabinet is slightly less than a hundred, unless you able to buy a 2nd hand dry box at $15 or $20, or manage to get a hand me down drybox, I don't see how much money can you save.

like many members already said before, unless you able to keep a good habit of checking drybox and maintaining the Silica gel regularly, don't you think trying not to open the dry cabinet more frequently, will make you use your camera lesser, isn't counter productive to own a camera this way?

Base on your post history, you didn't use drybox or dry cabinet when you bought your camera initially, and from your another thread, your lens already infest with fungus. FYI, fungus lens cleaning is around $120, if you already own a dry cabinet long ago, that shouldn't happen, this a valuable lesson for you to learn.

penny wise pound foolish, or enjoy your camera to the fullness, the choice is yours
 

Last edited:
Top Bottom