Are you bias towards newbies pictures?


Status
Not open for further replies.

jones24

New Member
Jul 7, 2009
160
1
0
#1
You know like sub consciously you see a new member that is new to photography and he shows his pictures will you just think that they are bad pictures simply because he is new?

You know human psychology is quite funny like the placebo effect where someone thinks he is eating real medicine and his brain makes his body well because of that.

I think this is a legitimate question.
 

daredevil123

Moderator
Staff member
Oct 25, 2005
21,660
68
48
lil red dot
#2
You know like sub consciously you see a new member that is new to photography and he shows his pictures will you just think that they are bad pictures simply because he is new?

You know human psychology is quite funny like the placebo effect where someone thinks he is eating real medicine and his brain makes his body well because of that.

I think this is a legitimate question.
No. Bad pictures are bad pictures, irregardless of who made them, oldie or newbie.

But there is a tendency for photographers to think too highly of their own work.

Even when I take a look at my older work, I also think they really suck. But that means I am improving, because my standards are now higher.

If you can remove yourself from the emotional attachment to your own pictures, and be your own harshest critic, you will improve very fast and go very far.
 

Last edited:
Jun 2, 2012
822
17
18
Singapore when back at home
#3
No. Bad pictures are bad pictures, irregardless of who made them, oldie or newbie.

But there is a tendency for photographers to think too highly of their own work.

Even when I take a look at my older work, I also think they really suck. But that means I am improving, because my standards are now higher.

If you can remove yourself from the emotional attachment to your own pictures, and be your own harshest critic, you will improve very fast and go very far.
I definitely concur with DD123 on this. :thumbsup:

I am my own worst & hardest critic.

Photography as in any hobby or profession needs honing. Review your shots and learn.
 

Jan 8, 2014
223
1
0
#4
I'll never critic a photo based on a photographer, but I will on what his photo tells me.
 

richiemccaw1

Senior Member
Feb 21, 2013
3,103
27
48
Singapore
#5
It is fair to feel a little defensive when being criticised, whether constructively or not. The important thing to do to improve is to take it in your stride! Thick skin and humility go a long way :))
 

shiosaki

Senior Member
May 16, 2012
832
33
28
#7
You know like sub consciously you see a new member that is new to photography and he shows his pictures will you just think that they are bad pictures simply because he is new?

You know human psychology is quite funny like the placebo effect where someone thinks he is eating real medicine and his brain makes his body well because of that.

I think this is a legitimate question.
dont think its legitimate.

because i think i have never heard a "newbie" being honestly good at anything. not only for photography.

i mean, do you see someone who is learning soccer telling the coach "hey im new, but i am good, i dont need training. i am ready to play for the national team"? dont think so. talent is talent, but it still needs to be nurtured.

i guess the point of TS posting this "might be" because that his photos has been badly critiqued for the past few days. not sure if posting randomly helped with this situation or not, but honestly, nobody is good in taking photos in a few weeks or even days. if it is so easy, people wouldnt be paying so much to buy images, hire photographers for weddings and events etc.
 

daredevil123

Moderator
Staff member
Oct 25, 2005
21,660
68
48
lil red dot
#8
i guess the point of TS posting this "might be" because that his photos has been badly critiqued for the past few days.
If that is really the case, then he should just say on his threads that critiques are not welcomed.

Anyway, I think I will stop commenting on his pictures. Seeing how sensitive he is, so I do not hurt his feelings.
 

Last edited:
Dec 12, 2012
871
9
0
Singapore
#9
Totally agree with daredevil123's first post. I don't think the people here are biased at all. Not biased against the experience of the photographer nor the equipment used.

Im relatively new to photography and every other shot I take looks like a winner to me. But once the others critique it, I often see how it can be improved. I think this is really important when it comes to helping yourself improve.

I would like to take the opportunity to add a couple of things too...

I've been reading with great interest ( and commenting where appropriate ) your posts. I think you feel that the photos you have taken are really good as well. And yet, when you receive critique(which you actually have asked for) I don't see you accept the critique and attempt to modify your shots and least try out the advice of the others. I mean, if you are really interested in the point of view of others, you would give heed to the advice offered and give it a shot. Isn't that right?

But I must say that the multitude of responses that you have received everytime you put up a post is very heartening to see. And I myself am relearning a lot from your posts and the advice you are receiving. It's like a refresher and reminder of the dos and donts. Thanks for adding value to the community with your posts and questions. And I'm proud to be a part of a forum where everyone is so ready to offer advice and constructive criticism. Good job ClubSnap!!!

One last thing though, you leave many threads hanging. Meaning to say that often times, you ask a question and just let the responses come in and you do not attempt to acknowledge or engage the person who responds to your thread. I feel that it would be nice if you do attempt to at least acknowledge the person who responds.
 

Last edited:

catchlights

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 27, 2004
21,903
46
48
Punggol, Singapore
www.foto-u.com
#10
You know like sub consciously you see a new member that is new to photography and he shows his pictures will you just think that they are bad pictures simply because he is new?

You know human psychology is quite funny like the placebo effect where someone thinks he is eating real medicine and his brain makes his body well because of that.

I think this is a legitimate question.
bad photos are bad photos, regardless is shot by who.

when a day I start thinking my photos re really "no horse run", and people don't appreciate my "art", that is the day I stop learning and improving
 

Mar 30, 2013
2,016
11
38
+65
#11
Hmm I don't think so. Do not agree at all. So many new members nowadays who have great pics but just created an account at CS to share their pictures.
 

catchlights

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 27, 2004
21,903
46
48
Punggol, Singapore
www.foto-u.com
#12
dont think its legitimate.

because i think i have never heard a "newbie" being honestly good at anything. not only for photography.

i mean, do you see someone who is learning soccer telling the coach "hey im new, but i am good, i dont need training. i am ready to play for the national team"? dont think so. talent is talent, but it still needs to be nurtured.

i guess the point of TS posting this "might be" because that his photos has been badly critiqued for the past few days. not sure if posting randomly helped with this situation or not, but honestly, nobody is good in taking photos in a few weeks or even days. if it is so easy, people wouldnt be paying so much to buy images, hire photographers for weddings and events etc.

if any members shooting, post processing and posting images without putting much efforts, please don't expect others also putting much efforts in return on commenting their photos.

that is reciprocate factors.

In fact, it is quite encouraging to see some members kind enough pointing the right direction to TS, however, how much can a person comprehend, that is really depends on him. :)
 

rhino123

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 1, 2006
5,243
15
38
NA
#13
You know like sub consciously you see a new member that is new to photography and he shows his pictures will you just think that they are bad pictures simply because he is new?

You know human psychology is quite funny like the placebo effect where someone thinks he is eating real medicine and his brain makes his body well because of that.

I think this is a legitimate question.
What make you say that? Are you guilty of what you says?

From what I see, in this forum, most (if not all) older members, new members, experts, seniors, etc are all very helpful in my photography journey. I am by far one of the lousiest photographer here (actually I am not even qualify to be a photographer, just a casual shooter), and when I post my pics up, people are friendly and pointed out my mistakes and let me learn.

If you re that sensitive to what others are saying... then I think you should not even post any photos up or ask any questions... Of course there are people here who are a bit more blunt than the others and what they say can be a bit harsh, but if only you take a while to think of what he/she had said, most actually made alot of sense.
 

kandinsky

Moderator
Staff member
Apr 26, 2008
3,014
24
38
#14
You know like sub consciously you see a new member that is new to photography and he shows his pictures will you just think that they are bad pictures simply because he is new?
Yes, of course! And when I see a senior member that is super experienced with photography, and he shows his pictures, I will think they are good pictures simply because he is experienced. I'm a slave to my subconscious mind and it always overrides all my other faculties (eyes, brain, etc.), and knowledge (logic, memories, experience, etc.) ;p
 

Last edited:

Zeisser

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2008
2,654
11
38
Tampines
www.flickr.com
#15
Perhaps TS had never tasted the critics of Deadpoet ,short and sharp. For me I always
remind myself 'am still learning'
 

dniwkh

New Member
Mar 19, 2012
840
9
0
#16
Perhaps TS had never tasted the critics of Deadpoet ,short and sharp. For me I always
remind myself 'am still learning'
deadpoet praised my newbie photo leh. that was one of the things that inspired to take more photos, the feeling that your photo meant something to people other than yourself.
 

nitewalk

Moderator
Staff member
May 31, 2010
4,646
35
48
Singapore
#17
Erm maybe u all might wanna see his thread of sentosa cove. I think many people have tried advising him but out comes one thanks plus truckload of excuses.
 

zeehamzah

Senior Member
Feb 8, 2011
1,307
6
38
#18
Erm maybe u all might wanna see his thread of sentosa cove. I think many people have tried advising him but out comes one thanks plus truckload of excuses.
I noticed that too.
Be it experienced or not, we learn from one another.
:)
 

SkyStrike

Moderator
Staff member
Nov 29, 2010
3,444
11
38
Somewhere
#19
You know like sub consciously you see a new member that is new to photography and he shows his pictures will you just think that they are bad pictures simply because he is new?

You know human psychology is quite funny like the placebo effect where someone thinks he is eating real medicine and his brain makes his body well because of that.

I think this is a legitimate question.
The final picture speaks louder than any words. Regardless of age, experience etc.

In short, if the picture is bad, it's bad.
 

#20
You know like sub consciously you see a new member that is new to photography and he shows his pictures will you just think that they are bad pictures simply because he is new?

You know human psychology is quite funny like the placebo effect where someone thinks he is eating real medicine and his brain makes his body well because of that.

I think this is a legitimate question.
Don't agree. It's more due to the style of criticism here that makes people think otherwise. Remember when u ask for feedback, you can get all sorts of feedback. It's up to you to be impartial and try to see from your critics pov. There is no real point in asking for criticism and see red when the critics go negative.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom