About charges for being in photographic competition...


Status
Not open for further replies.

zoossh

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2005
8,725
0
0
Singapore
#1
saw a competition that allows 10 photo submission per person but each photo submission cost US$4, so if you want to optimise your chance of winning, that will cost you US$40 for your entry.

is that the norm in competitions?
 

Dream Merchant

Moderator
Staff member
Jan 11, 2007
9,659
6
38
#2
I've seen similar in various competitions, in different industries, in different countries.

Seems it happens in many places. Why do you ask?
 

Dream Merchant

Moderator
Staff member
Jan 11, 2007
9,659
6
38
#4
Ah...well, I've seen it happen first (IIRC) back from the late 80s or early 90s in the USA mainly at high level competitions where awards usually spell a significant reason to demand a promotion and higher salary, and I guess SEA picked up on it much later.

The concept of 'paying' for an increased number of chances to win is not new. It's been there all the while in the guise of lotteries and lucky draws.

I guess some people think there might be something unethical about it, but the way it's generally viewed, it's only unethical if one party can out-buy opportunity more than another, or if the level of payment or purchases leverages an unfair advantage that may not be readily available to all interested.
 

attap seed

Senior Member
Feb 16, 2006
588
0
16
41
#5
such is the case all along in international salon, where there is a admin charge (abt usd10-15). and such competition dun hand out any prizes or cash. for the money, u can submit 4 entries and receive a catalog of winning entries at the end.
 

catchlights

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 27, 2004
21,903
46
48
Punggol, Singapore
www.foto-u.com
#6
OT abit,

I remember many many many years ago, a local professional photographers association holding a annual exhibition for their members, since at that time the association is still very new, didn't limit how many pieces of works for each member able to summit for the exhibition.

One photographer take this opportunity, summit many pieces of his work for that year exhibition, turn a group exhibition become his own solo exhibition.
 

Dream Merchant

Moderator
Staff member
Jan 11, 2007
9,659
6
38
#7
OT abit,

I remember many many many years ago, a local professional photographers association holding a annual exhibition for their members, since at that time the association is still very new, didn't limit how many pieces of works for each member able to summit for the exhibition.

One photographer take this opportunity, summit many pieces of his work for that year exhibition, turn a group exhibition become his own solo exhibition.
:bigeyes::bsmilie:
 

canturn

Senior Member
Sep 29, 2002
2,643
0
36
East, SG
www.lyricalmoments.com
#8
Some competitions can cost as much as USD$10-20 per entry and there isn't any so called market rate really. In some cases, there is a limit on the number of entries you can submit to the organisation in a year.

The competitions that I find are FOC in Singapore are usually an avenue for getting photos for a song for their own commercial use, ie, you'll noticed in their clauses things like "organisers reserves the right to the image anyhow, anywhere, anytime, on unlimited media, including those that might be invented in future throughout the universe". And all of us know, loading fees alone for commercial photography probably cost more than all the prize money. The way these folks do things here, is so darn cheap really.
 

zoossh

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2005
8,725
0
0
Singapore
#9
OT abit,

I remember many many many years ago, a local professional photographers association holding a annual exhibition for their members, since at that time the association is still very new, didn't limit how many pieces of works for each member able to summit for the exhibition.

One photographer take this opportunity, summit many pieces of his work for that year exhibition, turn a group exhibition become his own solo exhibition.
isn't it up to the organiser to select the works for exhibition??
 

catchlights

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 27, 2004
21,903
46
48
Punggol, Singapore
www.foto-u.com
#10
isn't it up to the organiser to select the works for exhibition??
as a member, I was shock to see this, how can it end up this way, I'm not in position to say anything.

anyway, at that time, the association is still very new, need alot supports from all it members, someone just take this opportunity to give his FULLY supports to the exhibition. ;)
 

zoossh

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2005
8,725
0
0
Singapore
#11
Some competitions can cost as much as USD$10-20 per entry and there isn't any so called market rate really. In some cases, there is a limit on the number of entries you can submit to the organisation in a year.

The competitions that I find are FOC in Singapore are usually an avenue for getting photos for a song for their own commercial use, ie, you'll noticed in their clauses things like "organisers reserves the right to the image anyhow, anywhere, anytime, on unlimited media, including those that might be invented in future throughout the universe". And all of us know, loading fees alone for commercial photography probably cost more than all the prize money. The way these folks do things here, is so darn cheap really.
but how often is gullible amateurs able to produce professional level works? i'm not implying anything as i truely didn't know the vast world outside. but i know for my works they are far below many in the bigger world outside cs (many good ones either seldom/dun post here, or dun even come into cs). sometimes i walk around the town seeing some exhibits, and there can be two kind of response to the standard of the entries... either "wow, i'm never be able to do that"... or "good takes. but i see better ones on the forum."

now if i presume the competition of certain standard, then i would expect the top three to be classics. i have no classics, nothing that i can say hey, that stands out a winner, while decent shots, there is quite a number. i'll be happy enough to win one of the lower consolation prices, if lucky enough. but the competition states no such things. only D60 as the third price.

now US$40 but almost 100% no chance of winning anything, i'm not sure if i'm really stingy (very likely i am). maybe keeping that for my next lens purchase of sigma 30mm f/1.4 or the next travel may be better. better be down to earth doing the practical stuff.

by the way, the competition is from singapore international photography festival. sounds very prestigious right?... must have some very solid entries. think better be the spectator.
http://am.sipf.com.sg/
 

zoossh

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2005
8,725
0
0
Singapore
#12
as a member, I was shock to see this, how can it end up this way, I'm not in position to say anything.

anyway, at that time, the association is still very new, need alot supports from all it members, someone just take this opportunity to give his FULLY supports to the exhibition. ;)
do u mean that there isn't many who submit their entries but since one photographer submit many (i supposed are good shots too), the organiser took all of them and display them??
 

catchlights

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 27, 2004
21,903
46
48
Punggol, Singapore
www.foto-u.com
#13
do u mean that there isn't many who submit their entries but since one photographer submit many (i supposed are good shots too), the organiser took all of them and display them??
yes, maybe at that time everyone is shy shy, or very busy. I dare not to show any photos, since I just a nobody at that time.
 

Aspect

New Member
Dec 2, 2004
75
0
0
#15
The competitions that I find are FOC in Singapore are usually an avenue for getting photos for a song for their own commercial use, ie, you'll noticed in their clauses things like "organisers reserves the right to the image anyhow, anywhere, anytime, on unlimited media, including those that might be invented in future throughout the universe". And all of us know, loading fees alone for commercial photography probably cost more than all the prize money. The way these folks do things here, is so darn cheap really.
Yeah, Pro-Imaging has a Bill of Rights to try to educate photographers and hopefully shame organizers to do the right thing :
The Bill of Rights for Photography Competitions
http://www.pro-imaging.org/content/view/177/132/1/1/
 

canturn

Senior Member
Sep 29, 2002
2,643
0
36
East, SG
www.lyricalmoments.com
#16
but how often is gullible amateurs able to produce professional level works? i'm not implying anything as i truely didn't know the vast world outside. but i know for my works they are far below many in the bigger world outside cs (many good ones either seldom/dun post here, or dun even come into cs). sometimes i walk around the town seeing some exhibits, and there can be two kind of response to the standard of the entries... either "wow, i'm never be able to do that"... or "good takes. but i see better ones on the forum."

now if i presume the competition of certain standard, then i would expect the top three to be classics. i have no classics, nothing that i can say hey, that stands out a winner, while decent shots, there is quite a number. i'll be happy enough to win one of the lower consolation prices, if lucky enough. but the competition states no such things. only D60 as the third price.

now US$40 but almost 100% no chance of winning anything, i'm not sure if i'm really stingy (very likely i am). maybe keeping that for my next lens purchase of sigma 30mm f/1.4 or the next travel may be better. better be down to earth doing the practical stuff.

by the way, the competition is from singapore international photography festival. sounds very prestigious right?... must have some very solid entries. think better be the spectator.
http://am.sipf.com.sg/

Few points to note, and sorry if I do OT a litte:

1. You don't have to be professional to produce kick-ass images. A professional is one who does it for a living, and doesn't mean non-professional produces inferior shots that can't be used commercially.

2. Despite these onerous clauses, some professionals still take part in these competitions. There was a recent one which I must have turned down at least 3 clients who asked me to shoot for them so that they can use the image for competition.

3. If you're going to create images for competition, you should be gunning for the top, after all the effort you've put in. You'll never know what the judges are looking at for.
 

attap seed

Senior Member
Feb 16, 2006
588
0
16
41
#17
the purpose of imposing a fee for every image can serve 2 purposes:

1. encourage the photographer to be critical of his own work

2. discourage ppl from submitting "inferior" work, jus to try their luck

imagine an free online competition (unlike submitting prints, which cost $$$) w attractive prizes. i am sure the response will be "over-whelming".

one potential problem will be instead of choosing the winning entries, the judges will be busy weeding out the poor ones. such culling can cause good photos to be removed early in the competition.

as for choosing between:

1. entering the competition
2. going on a tour
3. getting a new lens

why not survive on bread, on alternate days, for a yr and do all 3 :)?
 

zoossh

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2005
8,725
0
0
Singapore
#18
discourage ppl from submitting "inferior" work
yup. i think purpose fulfilled in my case.

3. If you're going to create images for competition, you should be gunning for the top, after all the effort you've put in. You'll never know what the judges are looking at for.
it is a travel photography competition. such trips can't be rushed, unless one is doing salon type shots where things are planned out and rely less on luck and surprise.

as for what the judges are looking for... if i presume they are really after real travel photographs and not for specific commerical purposes, they would be looking for something symbolic, original and aesthetically appealing.
 

zoossh

Senior Member
Nov 29, 2005
8,725
0
0
Singapore
#19
as for choosing between:

1. entering the competition
2. going on a tour
3. getting a new lens

why not survive on bread, on alternate days, for a yr and do all 3 :)?
i can only do good photographs in good mood and well being... ;)

i'm not sure about that... does most forumers really cut down on daily expenses so as to get their dream lens?? i often see that being said, but i dunno how often it is being practised.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom