A Review of D3X vs 5Dm2

[David Kwok]

http://www.kenrockwell.com/nikon/d3x/sharpness-comparison-5d-mark-ii.htm

Take note I post this link for further information only, it's definitely not an opportunity to kick a fuss between C and N users

Besides, what constitute a good picture is far more than just having sharp or blur images
Just my 2 cents worth

 

[ArcticFox]

I don't bother with his review because he only thinks that Nikon produces good camera.

 

[David Kwok]

I don't bother with his review because he only thinks that Nikon produces good camera.

Sometimes u just need to look at the pic There again, it is of course no reason to just take his words for it. Truth is outside

 

[lsisaxon]

I don't bother with his review because he only thinks that Nikon produces good camera.

Anyway, I do know some Canon users saying they're putting off buying the 5D2 because of certain artifacts even in the RAW files.

 

[ArcticFox]

Yeah, it's true that 5Dm2 it's not as good as D3X.

It's also not fair that he compares a D3X with a 5DmII he should have compared it with a 1DSmIII. Or, 5DmII with a D700.

 

[David Kwok]

Yeah, it's true that 5Dm2 it's not as good as D3X.

It's also not fair that he compares a D3X with a 5DmII he should have compared it with a 1DSmIII. Or, 5DmII with a D700.

So you feel it is fair to compare a 20+MP sensor with a 12MP sensor ? Isn't it even more unfair ? I can easily downsample the 20MP to 12MP and it can instantly look far sharper even if the sensor produce less sharp image at 20MP :bigeyes:

 

[ArcticFox]

Opss, I have forgotten a D700 is 12megapixel. Sorry :embrass:

 

[lsisaxon]

Yeah, it's true that 5Dm2 it's not as good as D3X.

It's also not fair that he compares a D3X with a 5DmII he should have compared it with a 1DSmIII. Or, 5DmII with a D700.

I think comparing with an A900 would be apt.

 

[chisiang]

I don't bother with his review because he only thinks that Nikon produces good camera.

As a Nikon user I also don't bother about him. :bsmilie:

I think a lot of newbies idolize him but eventually dump him once they turned more experienced.

He's always saying save this money and get that... or weight saving beats the sh|t out of quality... or this photo is straight out of a cheap camera on a cheap lens without processing...

 

[casio]

ken has always been funny..

btw, noise reduction at ISO100? hmm...

 

[Anson]

Look like people from this thread.... dun like him that much... :bsmilie:

 

[simranjits]

who is ken rockwell and why should we care??

 

[kcuf2]

who is ken rockwell and why should we care??

because this clown by the name of ken can rock & roll very well :thumbsup:

 

[mcn]

who is ken rockwell ??

u calling me ?

 

[ArcticFox]

http://www.bahneman.com/liem/blog/article.php?story=Ken_Rockwell_Facts

Some jokes about KRW.