I can't tell you if it's advisable, because I have no idea what lenses you have, how you use them, under what conditions nor what subjects you shoot more, but I can share that the Hoya ones with the red ring confused works well and is very durable under normal circumstances.
By having a lens hood! :bsmilie: - With a lens hood on you don't need to worry about lens cap anymore.
My Hoya rubber hoods can take the cap still. Either it's an earlier model or the descriptions on some websites are inaccurate.
I got mine from MS Color. Checked again with my lens caps. The 58mm original Canon lens cap works well, also OEM center pinch lens cap from OP. But the 67mm hood is built slightly differently, here the original Tamron lens cap doesn't work but again the 67mm OEM cap from OP works well. You might need to try with your lens cap before buying. But then again: with a hood the lens cap becomes redundant.