some crazy suggestion

zOOm · 15th June 2002

Critique Corner
...............................................
1. I find most of them don't follow guidelines set by the moderator. Perhaps popping up a message to remind people is a good idea?

2. Perhaps this critique corner should only allow a panel of selected ClubSNAP CTMs, super mod, chief, pros to post critics. This way, the quality of critique can be better controlled. else people / newbie like me might post "rubbish" & "amatuerish" review

The poster should be allow to post once with all the revalent details submited. Only the panels of "critics" can post while all others will have only read access.

3. Personally, I find people here was way too nice. It's not that it's no good. But aAt least critique conducted in Critique Corner should be more critical, instead of wrapping them up "sugar coating" everytime.

I felt these suggestion might just help to move the community a step forward. just some of my thoughts, no evil intention okay

OpenLens · 15th June 2002

I kinda agree just from looking around a bit...seems like an exchange of good comments (I'll give you a "That's nice if you give me a "Good job") rather than an accurate and honest critique. Is it that people here are too sensitive? I don't know...I just joined up today. Personally, I would like to see a heated conversation about composition under a photo with poor composition than a whole lot of "That's pretty" under a common flower macro or sunset. I think people would learn more this way, but only if they would actually participate in this manner. I don't think that comments should be restricted to a select few "experts"...this would be asking a lot of time and effort with no componsation from a small group of people.

15th June 2002

pro and con tho...
most of the people here are adult and most of them are photographer, unlike HWZ this forum is abt camera, and .... ppl like me who try to sort thing out for a living

the mod consider this forum mainly as a discussion base for SG photographer, unlike some i met, who is still soleing outside without knowing this forum for some reason. and i always introduce them to this forum just because there are lots of discussion and exchage in here which make ppl learn

like me i learn from, even tho not much but i am still learning, even tho i am not a photographer

anonymous · 25th June 2002

popping up a message is very irritating, i don't suggest this.

15th June 2002	#1
zOOm Member Join Date: May 2002 Location: Singapore Posts: 243	some crazy suggestion Critique Corner ............................................... 1. I find most of them don't follow guidelines set by the moderator. Perhaps popping up a message to remind people is a good idea? 2. Perhaps this critique corner should only allow a panel of selected ClubSNAP CTMs, super mod, chief, pros to post critics. This way, the quality of critique can be better controlled. else people / newbie like me might post "rubbish" & "amatuerish" review The poster should be allow to post once with all the revalent details submited. Only the panels of "critics" can post while all others will have only read access. 3. Personally, I find people here was way too nice. It's not that it's no good. But aAt least critique conducted in Critique Corner should be more critical, instead of wrapping them up "sugar coating" everytime. I felt these suggestion might just help to move the community a step forward. just some of my thoughts, no evil intention okay

15th June 2002	#2
OpenLens Member Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: Taipei, Taiwan/ Los Angeles, California. U.S.A. Posts: 376	I kinda agree just from looking around a bit...seems like an exchange of good comments (I'll give you a "That's nice if you give me a "Good job") rather than an accurate and honest critique. Is it that people here are too sensitive? I don't know...I just joined up today. Personally, I would like to see a heated conversation about composition under a photo with poor composition than a whole lot of "That's pretty" under a common flower macro or sunset. I think people would learn more this way, but only if they would actually participate in this manner. I don't think that comments should be restricted to a select few "experts"...this would be asking a lot of time and effort with no componsation from a small group of people. __________________ @Photojazz Blog @Cosina-Voigtlander.com

15th June 2002	#3
sunyee Guests Posts: n/a	pro and con tho... most of the people here are adult and most of them are photographer, unlike HWZ this forum is abt camera, and .... ppl like me who try to sort thing out for a living the mod consider this forum mainly as a discussion base for SG photographer, unlike some i met, who is still soleing outside without knowing this forum for some reason. and i always introduce them to this forum just because there are lots of discussion and exchage in here which make ppl learn like me i learn from, even tho not much but i am still learning, even tho i am not a photographer

25th June 2002	#4
anonymous Member Join Date: Feb 2002 Location: Silicon Valley Posts: 99	popping up a message is very irritating, i don't suggest this.