Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: Got some question to ask about macro lens

  1. #1

    Default Got some question to ask about macro lens

    Hi All,

    I got some questions to ask about macro lens....

    1) why macro lens has a focal length since their MFD is pretty short..so the focal length is for what use..?? for example .. a prime length 50mm f1.8..MFD is 45cm..and for a macro lens 100mm f2.8 got a MFD 31cm...so what the focal length of a macro lens mean??

    2) For example...when we want to shoot a snake..and we cant go near it to shoot and how does the macro lens work then?? In order to do a close up shoot of the snake??

    3) Any good macro lens to recommend??

  2. #2

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    u are confusing MFD and focal length. they have nothing to do with each other. the focal length is how near/far u see the object, while the MFD is how far u have to be at least from ur object to get in in focus.

    obviously using a 100mm lens (macro or not), ur object will appear alot closer compared to a 50mm. difference is that a macro lens allows u to shoot a 1:1 shot. meaning, ur photo will appear life size. the advantage of a 100mm macro over a 50mm macro is that u dun get bitten by the snake u are trying to take if u want a life size shot.

    canon has i think 3 macro lenses. 50/60mm(which allows up to 1:5 reproduction. meaning ur object can appear 5 times bigger than life size), 100mm as well as 180. difference being how far u can stay away from ur object AND STILL able to get a 1:1 reproduction.

  3. #3

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    Quote Originally Posted by nysheng View Post
    u are confusing MFD and focal length. they have nothing to do with each other. the focal length is how near/far u see the object, while the MFD is how far u have to be at least from ur object to get in in focus.

    obviously using a 100mm lens (macro or not), ur object will appear alot closer compared to a 50mm. difference is that a macro lens allows u to shoot a 1:1 shot. meaning, ur photo will appear life size. the advantage of a 100mm macro over a 50mm macro is that u dun get bitten by the snake u are trying to take if u want a life size shot.

    canon has i think 3 macro lenses. 50/60mm(which allows up to 1:5 reproduction. meaning ur object can appear 5 times bigger than life size), 100mm as well as 180. difference being how far u can stay away from ur object AND STILL able to get a 1:1 reproduction.
    so does it mean i stand 100mm away from my object..and lens will adjust till 1:1 production..before i release the shutter???

  4. #4

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    Quote Originally Posted by rysouke View Post
    so does it mean i stand 100mm away from my object..and lens will adjust till 1:1 production..before i release the shutter???
    The 100mm is the focal length, not the distance from the object to your lens.

    If the mimimum working distance is around 15cm, loosely put, when your object is 15cm from your lens, then you get 1:1 production.

    Edit: change Minimum focus distance to minimum working distance
    Last edited by ahbian; 29th November 2009 at 06:30 PM.

  5. #5
    Senior Member jlkk76's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Tampines
    Posts
    2,148

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    to solve ur problem, go rent the macro lens n test it urself...

    or simply find some1 for has it and let u try..

  6. #6

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    Quote Originally Posted by rysouke View Post
    so does it mean i stand 100mm away from my object..and lens will adjust till 1:1 production..before i release the shutter???
    no! pls do not confuse focal length with minimum focal distance.
    if u are using for example a canon 100mm macro whose MFD is abt 31cm. when the tip of the lens is 31cm from ur object, u will get a 1:1 reproduction. if u decide to move further away because ur composition is too tight, u will get lesser than 1:1 reproduction.

    if u want a 1:1 reproduction, the best way is to adjust ur lens using manual focus to 1:1 (ur lens should have a meter/dial of some sort), den adjust ur distance from ur object until it is in focus.

  7. #7

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    Quote Originally Posted by rysouke View Post
    so does it mean i stand 100mm away from my object..and lens will adjust till 1:1 production..before i release the shutter???
    Please read the newbies guides to photography posted here as well as searching online for "photography basics" and "focal length".

    Focal length is NOT the same as "distance from subject". It affects your angle of view.
    Alpha

  8. #8

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    Quote Originally Posted by nysheng View Post
    no! pls do not confuse focal length with minimum focal distance.
    if u are using for example a canon 100mm macro whose MFD is abt 31cm. when the tip of the lens is 31cm from ur object, u will get a 1:1 reproduction. if u decide to move further away because ur composition is too tight, u will get lesser than 1:1 reproduction.

    if u want a 1:1 reproduction, the best way is to adjust ur lens using manual focus to 1:1 (ur lens should have a meter/dial of some sort), den adjust ur distance from ur object until it is in focus.
    Slight correction, because I made the mistake also. From tip of lens to object is minimum working distance, not minimum focusing distance.

  9. #9

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    Quote Originally Posted by nysheng View Post
    no! pls do not confuse focal length with minimum focal distance.
    if u are using for example a canon 100mm macro whose MFD is abt 31cm. when the tip of the lens is 31cm from ur object, u will get a 1:1 reproduction. if u decide to move further away because ur composition is too tight, u will get lesser than 1:1 reproduction.

    if u want a 1:1 reproduction, the best way is to adjust ur lens using manual focus to 1:1 (ur lens should have a meter/dial of some sort), den adjust ur distance from ur object until it is in focus.
    Ok..i got what you mean by now....

  10. #10

    Default Re: Got some question to ask about macro lens

    Quote Originally Posted by ahbian View Post
    Slight correction, because I made the mistake also. From tip of lens to object is minimum working distance, not minimum focusing distance.
    sorry..my fault...

    the miminum working distance is distance from tip of lens to object. the minimum focusing distance is distance from ur sensor to object.

    To TS: take the MFD - (the length of ur lens) = minimum distance from lens tip to ur object.

    hope it's clearer now..

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •