Filter for Canon 10-22mm

[ahbian]

Hi everyone,

I am considering getting the 10-22mm lens, need some advice.

If I were to get a UV filter, must it necessary be the slim version?

Any problems with vignetting due to whichever filters you used?

Feedback appreciated!

[tony_teo]

I using the normal filter. Very slight vignetting at 10mm, but can be easily cleaned up during post processing.

[Russ]

You will need slim filters if you shoot 10mm and use 2 filters - e.g. UV plus C polariser. Either that or you have to swap filters or do the no filter thingy (taking care of course).

[ahbian]

Ok, already bought the lens.

Seems like there is a trade-off, slim filter --> unable to attach lens cover.

Still, I guess shouldnt let such things distract from the main aim - just shoot!

Thanks for all the replies!

[repusez]

anyone know if there'll be any vignetting if i were to use the standard size B+W CPL filter on the canon 10-22 ?

[anneanne]

hi repusez, I am actually using B+W CPL on 10-22. there won't be vignetting unless you decide to stack it on top to another normal filter for easy removal.

[FilterFunk]

Originally Posted by anneanne hi repusez, I am actually using B+W CPL on 10-22. there won't be vignetting unless you decide to stack it on top to another normal filter for easy removal.

erm, so am i right to assume that if you stack 2 non-slim filters together you will get vignetting? or am i wrong ?

[anneanne]

ERM... well yes? hehehe but bcoz CPL filter is thicker than normal filter, almost twice the size of a normal filter... so stacking a CPL and a normal filter is like 3 filter together. very obvious dark edge can be seen... hee

[FilterFunk]

nevermind, i will post my findings later by next week when i get to try both a slim and non-slim filter

[shocky]

Originally Posted by FilterFunk erm, so am i right to assume that if you stack 2 non-slim filters together you will get vignetting? or am i wrong ?

stack 2 definitely will..

In fact you get more than just vignetting, you will get a dark ring at 10mm

So remove UV when u put on CPL

[miniUltraman]

I have used both slim and non-slim B+W MRC 010 on my 10-22 (without stacking, of course)... No vignetting. 10-22 is a good lens!!! Enjoy

[blueskye168]

Originally Posted by miniUltraman I have used both slim and non-slim B+W MRC 010 on my 10-22 (without stacking, of course)... No vignetting. 10-22 is a good lens!!! Enjoy

I have used 77mm for both slim-B+W Cir-Pol) and normal/non-slim B+W UV-MRC010 on my 10-22 = no stacking=NO vignetting but when I stack it even with my slim-B+W Cir-Pol only very minor(to me) corner vignetting occurred.

[Stratix]

i'm using normal Hoya Super HMC filter on it. dont seem to have caused any major form of vignetting that would give me quirks. =)