Suggestion for Critique Corner

[Yatlapball]

Hello,

With regards to the 1 post per week, would it be possible to relax it somewhat? Perhaps with an additional clause.

How about "One post per week from one theme only"?

Thus allowing users who have shot loads of different themes to put up their best of each theme for critique. e.g. One portrait. One landscape. One macro... per week

I feel uh... somewhat constipated by the current rule.

[eikin]

Originally Posted by Yatlapball Hello, With regards to the 1 post per week, would it be possible to relax it somewhat? Perhaps with an additional clause. How about "One post per week from one theme only"? Thus allowing users who have shot loads of different themes to put up their best of each theme for critique. e.g. One portrait. One landscape. One macro... per week I feel uh... somewhat constipated by the current rule.

thanks for the suggestion, definitely will consider relaxing the rules

thematic differentiation may not work well since some pictures do qualify for different themes at one time.

will propose to have the time limit shortened to 3-4 days for a start.

[eikin]

btw other suggestions always welcomed

[Yatlapball]

Hmmm okay. I thought basing it on theme would work. Since that is similar to how the gallery section is separated anyway.

Yeah I agree that some photos qualify for more than one theme, but I guess the user can be "forced" to choose one.

[eikin]

Originally Posted by Yatlapball Hmmm okay. I thought basing it on theme would work. Since that is similar to how the gallery section is separated anyway. Yeah I agree that some photos qualify for more than one theme, but I guess the user can be "forced" to choose one.

will bring the idea up for discussion with the other superusers and mods