Results 1 to 11 of 11

Thread: Some purple flowers

  1. #1

    Default Some purple flowers

    Hi guys..
    Spotted this pot of small purple flowers planted by my gran.. so decided to take a couple pics of it.. somehow can't get much detail from the top part of the flower that's in focus.. what settings (lighting / camera settings / shading / PP) would probably bring out the most details from the flower?

    I did darken the picture a tad bit, if not the top would look like a blob of purple.




    Thanks for any C&C.

    Cheers,
    Andrew

  2. #2
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2002
    Location
    Somewhere near Equator
    Posts
    210

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    Probably you need to share your settings when you took this pictures. It will give more ideas for bros/sis here to response.

  3. #3

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    Here're the settings..

    Canon EOS 350D DIGITAL
    1/250"
    F2.8
    Aperture priority
    100
    +0.67EV
    Pattern
    Flash did not fire
    59mm

    Erm.. looking at the exif i just realised that I set it to +0.67EV.. That could be the reason why I needed to darken the picture in PP..

  4. #4

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    negative space dont work - unbalances the pic; focus is good, but can be deeper, but nothing can be done there in PP; over saturated, lost textures and details in the pink, can possibly be recovered with curves; bluish tint, eg the leaves are a strange green, possibly overcast skies when shot, need WB correction; and finally perhaps a square format.

  5. #5

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    Quote Originally Posted by espion View Post
    negative space dont work - unbalances the pic; focus is good, but can be deeper, but nothing can be done there in PP; over saturated, lost textures and details in the pink, can possibly be recovered with curves; bluish tint, eg the leaves are a strange green, possibly overcast skies when shot, need WB correction; and finally perhaps a square format.
    Hi espion, thanks for your comments.
    What do you mean about focus can be deeper? Is it DOF can be deeper, focus point can be deeper or you meant composition wise?

    I did abit of PP on the picture (desaturated + adjustment of red & blue curve). What do you think of the following pic?


  6. #6

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    details in pink better, still bluish on my screen - and there are more precise ways of correcting WB, than agar-agar.

    but compositionally I dunno how to tell you how to place the objects, but as it, is worst then previously - u must have sense of "balance", now it is unbalanced yet.

    You still need the negative space on left, to balance the three blobs of pink but not as much as previously. Where is this aesthetic optimum, and their proportions, square or otherwise, you must have the eye for it, and there are more ways than one, but this way is not. one guide is the rule of thirds ...

    deeper DOF means more of the entire flower in focus and not just the frontal surface, maybe up to 2/3 into the flower, in this particular case.
    Last edited by espion; 26th February 2007 at 06:50 PM.

  7. #7
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    東京 Tokyo
    Posts
    10,193

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    thank you for sharing this picture here chewraisins,
    i think it provides opportunities to demonstrate a
    couple of points about composition.

    first of all you need to identify what's 'useful' elements
    inside the frame, which obviously are the purple flowers.



    as shown above, the purple flower at the bottom right edge
    seems like an offending element that upsets the balance of
    the picture. as such, an initial consideration will be to remove
    it 1. via cloning tool or 2. via cropping



    with such an empty frame, it's convenient to place your subject
    at the centre at times, like above. however the composition is
    still lopsided due to the fact that the left side is simply too empty.
    as mentioned by espion a square crop may suit the subjects. it
    is easier to balance the visual weight of the elements in this frame
    in a square crop because it effectively increase the
    object:space proportion here



    cutting into the out of focus flowers effectively reduce their visual
    weight as well.

    looking back at the picture, there are actually more ways to treat
    the picture. personally i would like to express the flower in focus
    together with the leaves.



    and i might want to make use of a panoramic frame to emphasis that abit



    the long frame will take advantage of the space on the left as extended space
    of the subject's environment. pressing down on the top and bottom of the frame
    together with the central placement of the main subject pushes viewer's first
    impression onto the main subject itself before visually wandering off to the sides.

    there are many ways to compose this, do try out and have fun.

  8. #8

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    Eikin, a gd n enriching reply there. Will try tat out too. Having some problems with having gd compositions. mayb you can point some out on my post too. Thank you.

  9. #9

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    Hi espion, thanks for your comments & advice.
    I'll look up the net for more info regarding composition & rule of thirds. Noted regarding DOF.
    By the way, how do we adjust white balance on a picture without any "pure" grey/white objects?

    Hi eikin, thanks a million on the informative post.. it helps alot for a noob like me.. I'll certainly try out the different ways to compose this picture.

    Cheers,
    Andrew

  10. #10

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    Just to add to eikin's cropping possibilities, you can also rotate the frame, and that compound the compositional solutions.

    As to WB correction, in this case you have a bit of white in the stamen/pistil of some the florets. They can be used.

    And where you have no white/grey reference at all, you either use custom WB at the time of shot - just carry a white card with you - or use another reference colour if you have to do it post-imaging.

    Here the reference could be the "green" in the leaves. Select a reference point and tweaked its RGB, eg 2.5:1:1 for G:R:B or some other ratio, until it looks OK to your eye on the screen. But in reality "green" is not pure G, but has some differing proportions of R and B, and as such the eye - and the screen calibration - is key. This is of course the most agar agar of methods, as tentative as agar agar itself.

    But at the end of the day, unless your photo is used for scientific purposes, eg analysis of the star images from the Hubble telescope - and even there Photoshop is used as an analysis tool - it is the aesthetics that makes the final call, ie it is not whether it is right or wrong, but whether it looks good or bad. And how to get this eye to see good or bad, again I don't know.
    Last edited by espion; 27th February 2007 at 01:16 PM.

  11. #11

    Default Re: Some purple flowers

    sorry to ot but eikin, your explanation is superb!

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •