Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 45

Thread: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

  1. #1

    Default Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Hi. I have an Iomega ext HD 80GB which is my only backup HD. It has been serving me well but is running out of space. Lately, my school photography club's main ext hard disk crashed and files were totally not recoverble . It's a Seagate. So right now, i would like a firm and confident recommendation of which ext HD to use. I know Iomega is expensive, but do their quality justify their pricing? If they do, i dun mind paying the extra just to have a peace of mind. and also, this hard disk must be able to survive long periods of storage time in the dry box. For eg, some of my very important critical yet not oftenly opened files are currently saved into a stack of zip disks i have as they give me the confidence that they can survive stale storage for a long time(which i think is true as these disks are like 10-12 years old.)

    Overall, i just need a good reliable ext HD, which i dun mind paying extra if it is really good, and must survive stale storage(meaning left untouched) for long periods of time. thanks!

    btw, i have removed seagate from my list as my club's HD crashing is one of a nightmare, imagine 2 whole years of photographs of events just *poof*. though i might be quite unfair to seagate, i think it is just a physchological comfort not to use something i saw broken before.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Hey Satay

    Many yeas back, i used to love ibm for its branding and good QC for hdd. However, in today's contaxt, i don't really care.

    There is not one brand that can provide absolute guarantee against failure. Even the mtbf (mean time before failure) chart does not mean much as those were tested in the most ideal conditions. Go with reputable brands. And btw, Iomega does not manufature hdd. They simply get people to manufacture for them. Their role is more marketing, packaging and software solutioning.

    HDD dependability is pure luck these days. It is rather unfair to mark a certain due to failures - unless there is a batch problem. A spec of micron size dirt caught up on a needle can jazz up the disc surface and will wipe off data suddenly when the dirt builts up in size.

    Multiple backups is perhaps the safest bet. Ever wonder why there are raids systems created? The answer is reducing probability before failure. (my own term: RPBF)

  3. #3
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    AMK
    Posts
    2,340

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    I need this thread.

    Considering getting a Samsung 2.5 80GB with external case at $131 (Case is twin usb powered or optional AC)

    or the LaCie Mobile Hard Disk, 80GB 2.5 USB 2.0: http://www.lacie.com/asia/products/p....htm?pid=10651

    Anyone with any product experience to share or tips to lookout for?

    I know it's the IDE Chip/Board that translate into better speed transfer of HDD.
    I'm tempted to get the LaCie though.

  4. #4
    Moderator ortega's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    Singapore, Singapore, Singapor
    Posts
    23,686
    Blog Entries
    7

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    all HDD will die one day
    look for MTBF rating

    Since all HDD will die, the HDD is just a temp storage space
    I use 2 x 160GB HDDs Raid 1 and burn 2X DVDs

    One for storage and one for use.

  5. #5
    Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    Singapore, CCK, SK
    Posts
    165

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Hi satay, u getting for sch or personal use?
    If for sch u may like to check out the NAS (Network Attached Storage). Its min is 250GB and some have FTP function in built. Its bulky compared to those ext HDD.

    For personal user, u may like to check out the less expensive Ext HDD (1.8"/2.5"). These are the small size ext HDD.

    Can visit http://hardwarezone.com.sg/priceguide/cat.php?id=191 for more info.
    Last edited by match80; 11th October 2006 at 09:21 AM.
    400D | 17-85mm f4.0-5.6 | 50mm f1.8 | 55-200mm f4.5-5.6 | 28-105mm f3.5-4.5 | 430EXII |
    My Pics

  6. #6
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2003
    Location
    Outside the Dry Box.
    Posts
    16,268

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Quote Originally Posted by ortega View Post
    all HDD will die one day
    look for MTBF rating

    Since all HDD will die, the HDD is just a temp storage space
    I use 2 x 160GB HDDs Raid 1 and burn 2X DVDs

    One for storage and one for use.
    power... i still JSOB all my drive... haha... currently all sata... 320x2, 200x4, or is it the other way round... used up liao...
    Logging Off. "You have 2,631 messages stored, of a total 400 allowed." don't PM me.

  7. #7

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    I am using V-Gear LANDISK for my data storage like photos at home. I also backup my data into DVD-Rs and keep them in my dry cabinet.
    See my Photo Gallery at the Clubsnap

  8. #8
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Singapore, Bedok
    Posts
    1,785

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Quote Originally Posted by satay16 View Post
    Hi. I have an Iomega ext HD 80GB which is my only backup HD. It has been serving me well but is running out of space. Lately, my school photography club's main ext hard disk crashed and files were totally not recoverble . It's a Seagate. So right now, i would like a firm and confident recommendation of which ext HD to use. I know Iomega is expensive, but do their quality justify their pricing? If they do, i dun mind paying the extra just to have a peace of mind. and also, this hard disk must be able to survive long periods of storage time in the dry box. For eg, some of my very important critical yet not oftenly opened files are currently saved into a stack of zip disks i have as they give me the confidence that they can survive stale storage for a long time(which i think is true as these disks are like 10-12 years old.)

    Overall, i just need a good reliable ext HD, which i dun mind paying extra if it is really good, and must survive stale storage(meaning left untouched) for long periods of time. thanks!

    btw, i have removed seagate from my list as my club's HD crashing is one of a nightmare, imagine 2 whole years of photographs of events just *poof*. though i might be quite unfair to seagate, i think it is just a physchological comfort not to use something i saw broken before.
    When you say 'i dun mind paying extra', how much is your 'extra'? Coz if u really want to feel safe, that 'extra' might be a lot extra.

    First, forget DVDs. 1) They WILL fail. 2) You DON'T KNOW when they've failed until you try to read them (ie too late). 3) If your data grows by even a modest few GB a month, you'd find yourself managing hundreds of them after a while.

    i've been doing the 'burn a copy' thing for a while, dutifully numbering my DVDs; gave up at around #100 or so. It takes (min) 15-30min to verify ONE DVD, so realistically/practically, i don't know how many of my DVDs are still ok. (Oh, i stick to branded ones too.) Even if they are ALL ok, it would take me 50-100 hours for a full recovery should the necessity arise.

    (You can replace 'zip disk' with 'DVD' for above argument, and change the numbers a bit.)

    On to harddisks. They are mechnical devices, they are designed to fail eventually. It does not matter what external hdd you get; if it's a 1-hdd system, they WILL be a crash someday, and you're back to square one - one crash all gone.

    The only storage media designed for long term 'stale storage' are magnetic backup tapes. Good luck trying to find one. They are also very slow, and obviously nobody can yet verify their 100(?) years longevity claim.

    You can consider an 'active' storage system. The most basic is backing it up to another harddisk. Use a RAID1 (mirror) if you want this done automactically. You'd have to pay double for your storage space. There are external enclosures that hold 2 hdds and support RAID0/1; check out Storage Studio at Sim Lim. They go for around $200-$300 for the empty case.

    The next step up would be a RAID5 system. You get n-1 capacity for n disks. For example, a 4x250GB RAID5 would get you 750GB. The cool thing about RAID5 is that you can carry on working when 1 disk fails, and you just replace the spoiled disk and the RAID5 system rebuilds itself. External RAID5 systems usually come with Gigabit LAN, as well as USB and/or Firewire. The casings range cost range from $800 to ard $2k. However, since they typically take 4HDDs inside, while being 'external' they are not really portable.

  9. #9

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Quote Originally Posted by ST1100 View Post
    When you say 'i dun mind paying extra', how much is your 'extra'? Coz if u really want to feel safe, that 'extra' might be a lot extra.

    First, forget DVDs. 1) They WILL fail. 2) You DON'T KNOW when they've failed until you try to read them (ie too late). 3) If your data grows by even a modest few GB a month, you'd find yourself managing hundreds of them after a while.

    i've been doing the 'burn a copy' thing for a while, dutifully numbering my DVDs; gave up at around #100 or so. It takes (min) 15-30min to verify ONE DVD, so realistically/practically, i don't know how many of my DVDs are still ok. (Oh, i stick to branded ones too.) Even if they are ALL ok, it would take me 50-100 hours for a full recovery should the necessity arise.

    (You can replace 'zip disk' with 'DVD' for above argument, and change the numbers a bit.)

    On to harddisks. They are mechnical devices, they are designed to fail eventually. It does not matter what external hdd you get; if it's a 1-hdd system, they WILL be a crash someday, and you're back to square one - one crash all gone.

    The only storage media designed for long term 'stale storage' are magnetic backup tapes. Good luck trying to find one. They are also very slow, and obviously nobody can yet verify their 100(?) years longevity claim.

    You can consider an 'active' storage system. The most basic is backing it up to another harddisk. Use a RAID1 (mirror) if you want this done automactically. You'd have to pay double for your storage space. There are external enclosures that hold 2 hdds and support RAID0/1; check out Storage Studio at Sim Lim. They go for around $200-$300 for the empty case.

    The next step up would be a RAID5 system. You get n-1 capacity for n disks. For example, a 4x250GB RAID5 would get you 750GB. The cool thing about RAID5 is that you can carry on working when 1 disk fails, and you just replace the spoiled disk and the RAID5 system rebuilds itself. External RAID5 systems usually come with Gigabit LAN, as well as USB and/or Firewire. The casings range cost range from $800 to ard $2k. However, since they typically take 4HDDs inside, while being 'external' they are not really portable.
    cool(about the raid 5 thingy). how does it store a backup in just one extra disk?

  10. #10

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    in today context there is no 100% safe even if you buy well build high end drive. the correct way is to do mirror on your data thats reduce your failure chance by 50% if mirrorX2 you futher reduce by another 50% of 50%. Seagate is the largest HDD company in the world, they don't get there by luck.

  11. #11
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    Gim Boon Tai
    Posts
    2,909

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    I run a Raid 5 on my Buffalo Terastation NAS. It's slower than a directly connected harddisk, but serves well as a huge capacity storage that's isolated from my main pc.
    If you understand my works, it's photography. If you don't, it's art.
    SplutterPhotography|flickr

  12. #12

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    I work in the HD industry. The best advise I can give is buy a hard disk with the longest warranty period you can find.

    Cheers,

    Al

  13. #13

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    hmmm.........ok. so right now, if i just one to buy one ext hard disk, not horrendously expensive, tell me what to buy. just name one. size about 100-200GB enuf liao.

  14. #14

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    got myself a a 320gb for $230 two days ago.
    seagate Hdd with exter enclosure
    头可断,血可流,倩女不可不追求 carpe diem,when in doubt, hoot first,apologise later:p GALLERY

  15. #15

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Quote Originally Posted by eow View Post
    got myself a a 320gb for $230 two days ago.
    seagate Hdd with exter enclosure
    nooooo...........no seagate for me... explaination above.

  16. #16
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Singapore, Bedok
    Posts
    1,785

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Quote Originally Posted by satay16 View Post
    cool(about the raid 5 thingy). how does it store a backup in just one extra disk?

    It uses parity bits and spreads them across all disks; if one disk goes down, the data on the remaining disks are sufficient to rebuild the crashed disk.

    The calculation of the parity info is unfortunately very CPU intensive, and tends to slow the CPU down quite a bit. There are RAID5 cards that do the computation on board, but they cost a lot more.

  17. #17
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2003
    Location
    Singapore, Bedok
    Posts
    1,785

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Quote Originally Posted by Splutter View Post
    I run a Raid 5 on my Buffalo Terastation NAS. It's slower than a directly connected harddisk, but serves well as a huge capacity storage that's isolated from my main pc.
    i'm using this too. Very nice and quiet system; but really really slow. 5-15 mb/s transfer, quite a joke since it comes with a gigabit LAN connection. The CPU cannot keep up with the (software) raid5 computations. Think they underpowered the CPU to keep the cost, heat and noise down, pity.

  18. #18

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Quote Originally Posted by satay16 View Post
    nooooo...........no seagate for me... explaination above.
    Aiyah... no matter Seagate, Maxtor, Samsung or .... there is always a possibility of failures...

    I used to be a failue analysis engineer in one of the HDD company... I know...


  19. #19

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    Quote Originally Posted by Scaglietti View Post
    Aiyah... no matter Seagate, Maxtor, Samsung or .... there is always a possibility of failures...

    I used to be a failue analysis engineer in one of the HDD company... I know...

    That is why i still trust the good old FILM, well kept and protected, it will definitely
    outlast me.

    Just my 2 cents.

  20. #20

    Default Re: Recommendation needed for ext hard disk.

    yes same go with my maxtor,western digital...all prone to failure..
    just get a new asap once u sense something wrong with the hdd
    头可断,血可流,倩女不可不追求 carpe diem,when in doubt, hoot first,apologise later:p GALLERY

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •