Some B&W still-life. Comments & Critics welcomed

[Autumnite]

#1


#2


#3


#4


Do lemme know ur comments...

[JediForce4ever]

I love the second shot!!

[1Ds]

#2

[velasco]

hi i extemely love the sharpness of the pictures. Esp 1 and 2!

[lastboltnut]

Duno why, I just like #1....keep looking at it. The contrast is good....and I am thinking is the top crate of drink still filled with drink? While the bottom crate is definitely emptied....

[Autumnite]

Thanks guys for the positive comments. Trying on B&W pictures but not sure of the right way B&W pictures should be, esp the right contrast and tonal range stuff. Ur comments means i'm on the right track/somewhere there

[bwilly]

#1 & #2 good.
The other two to me not pleasing.
U took in B&W or colour then adjust to B&W?

[Autumnite]

Took in colour and converted to black and white...

For the other 2, is it cause of the B&W contrast/tonal range tt i am doing wrong? or is it cause of the composition?

[princej]

Nice shots

No: 4 reminded me of my kampung (village) here in Singapore.

Thanks.

[Evil_Angle]

P2 and P4 are nice~~

[Autumnite]

Quote: No: 4 reminded me of my kampung (village) here in Singapore.

yup there's still lots of these scene in my country

[bwilly]

Originally Posted by Autumnite Took in colour and converted to black and white... For the other 2, is it cause of the B&W contrast/tonal range tt i am doing wrong? or is it cause of the composition?

Subject not interesting.. haha..
#3 to me, looks too messy.. though the tonal looks good.
#4 uninteresting subject n the angle.

[redstone]

#2's great!

Would be better if there's more range.