Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 30

Thread: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

  1. #1

    Smile Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    your comment(knowledgeable ones pls) pls. with transaction records through sms and/or CS private messages, if one party decides to bring the case to small claims tribunal with such records of transactions, is it acceptable to them?

  2. #2

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    if you buy something from someone, i.e. pay money in return for xyz, then a contract comes into existence... even without any evidence in writing.

  3. #3
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Jurong Lake District - West
    Posts
    897

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    iirc small claims tribunal is for non payment cases. i do not think it applies to Csers who bidded successfully B&S prices and does not turn up.

  4. #4

    Smile Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    having bidded successfully and not fulfilling the financial obligation, as a result of, is an instance of 'non-payment' cases. right?

    Quote Originally Posted by ernest_ted
    iirc small claims tribunal is for non payment cases. i do not think it applies to Csers who bidded successfully B&S prices and does not turn up.

  5. #5
    Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    Singapore
    Posts
    1,021

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Quote Originally Posted by reachme2003
    having bidded successfully and not fulfilling the financial obligation, as a result of, is an instance of 'non-payment' cases. right?
    I believe that goods would have had to be delivered also.

  6. #6
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Location
    KFC
    Posts
    1,777

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    alrite...i will just state what i still remember from what i learned from business law. in the statute, even for transactions such as auctions, when the time is up and the deal is closed, both the buyer and seller are legally binded to each other and a legally binding contract would be formed between the 2 of them, and they MUST both fulfill their obligations i.e. seller - to send the goods over & buyer - to make payment.

    The only way the contract will be voided is only when BOTH parties agreed to change the terms of the contract, otherwise if its only the wish of one party, the contract is legally binding on the 2 parties, and the one at the loss can claim damages for anything that resulted from their non-fulfillment of its contractual duties.

    but the problem with clubsnap auction site is that, if there is any mention that despite the auction being closed, and the item is subjected to review by the buyer, PERSONALLY i feel that the contract is not formed yet, thus u cant claim anything. but if the buyer just say ok without mentioning anything, that will be a different story.

    disclaimer: Take what i wrote as just a textbook guide, dun quote me for anything k
    09 Oct 09 officially marks the date I become a canon convert.

  7. #7

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Yes. The law of contract applies everywhere a contract is made.

    However, to have sufficiently accurate and detailed records in the form of sms is difficult, since a lot of promises (esp. in terms of condition of the product, etc) are likely to be verbal and subjective.

    To take someone to small claims tribunal you must be able to serve notice upon the person, ie you need his real name in full and address, prob IC no as well to positively identify him.

    I don't see why you should do so, it's a lot of trouble got very little gain.

    Quote Originally Posted by reachme2003
    your comment(knowledgeable ones pls) pls. with transaction records through sms and/or CS private messages, if one party decides to bring the case to small claims tribunal with such records of transactions, is it acceptable to them?

  8. #8

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Though I am not a legal professional, this is at least what I know of contract law.

    Stating that the actual sale is subjected to review up front will effectly mean that is a "condition" of sales. Hence, the buyer or seller may refuse to sell if a reasonable reason is given.

    However, there are several factors that should be considered. Was there "consideration". Since the seller is parting with his good and the buyer is willing to part with this money, than there is consideration. Regardless if the "consideration" is adaquate. Even if I am going to offer S$1 for a 600mm lens, it is still consideration.

    Next is the intention to create a "legal" relationship. A buyer and seller relationship should be a legal relationship already, where the ownership of items is exchanged.

    Next we would need to look into wether the seller was putting up an "offer" to sell or "an invitation to treat". If it is an "offer" to sell, than with the above 2 condition satisfied, than the buyer, on the surface of things, is legally binded to sell. If it was "an invitation to treat", than the seller is not obliged to sell even if a buyer takes up the "invitation".
    How to differentiate an 'invitation to treat' or 'offer', we would need to consult a lawyer.

    And I would think that the law of contract does apply to B&S in CS.

  9. #9

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Quote Originally Posted by ernest_ted
    iirc small claims tribunal is for non payment cases. i do not think it applies to Csers who bidded successfully B&S prices and does not turn up.
    I am not sure what iirc means but..................................

    The small claims tribunal has jurisdation to hear cases where there are monetary claim.
    The Registrar is empowered to hear cases with claims not exceeding 10k and may be allowed to hear claims up to 20k if both party to the case give their consent.

  10. #10
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Jurong Lake District - West
    Posts
    897

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Quote Originally Posted by reachme2003
    having bidded successfully and not fulfilling the financial obligation, as a result of, is an instance of 'non-payment' cases. right?
    IMHO
    There is an invitation to treat and an offer.
    There is no acceptance and no consideration being exchanged.
    Hence no financial obligation. Also no loss to either party.

    However , i stand corrected.

  11. #11
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Jurong Lake District - West
    Posts
    897

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Quote Originally Posted by Ren_Hao
    I am not sure what iirc means but..................................

    .
    iirc ==> if i remembered correctly

  12. #12
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Jurong Lake District - West
    Posts
    897

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Quote Originally Posted by Ren_Hao
    Though I am not a legal professional, this is at least what I know of contract law.

    Stating that the actual sale is subjected to review up front will effectly mean that is a "condition" of sales. Hence, the buyer or seller may refuse to sell if a reasonable reason is given.

    However, there are several factors that should be considered. Was there "consideration". Since the seller is parting with his good and the buyer is willing to part with this money, than there is consideration. Regardless if the "consideration" is adaquate. Even if I am going to offer S$1 for a 600mm lens, it is still consideration.

    Next is the intention to create a "legal" relationship. A buyer and seller relationship should be a legal relationship already, where the ownership of items is exchanged.

    Next we would need to look into wether the seller was putting up an "offer" to sell or "an invitation to treat". If it is an "offer" to sell, than with the above 2 condition satisfied, than the buyer, on the surface of things, is legally binded to sell. If it was "an invitation to treat", than the seller is not obliged to sell even if a buyer takes up the "invitation".
    How to differentiate an 'invitation to treat' or 'offer', we would need to consult a lawyer.

    And I would think that the law of contract does apply to B&S in CS.
    Things that are displyed on shelves on supermarket with price tag ==> invitation to treat not an offer.
    When u put the item in your trolley does not mean u have accepted the offer.
    Only at the check out when u pay, u have accepted the offer.

    Am i right....gee...contract law classes were many moons ago..
    Last edited by ernest_ted; 4th June 2006 at 04:43 PM.

  13. #13

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Quote Originally Posted by ernest_ted
    Things that are displyed on shelves on supermarket with price tag ==> invitation to treat not an offer.
    When u put the item in your trolley does not mean u have accepted the offer.
    Only that the check out when u pay, u have accepted the offer.
    You are rite, that is an classic example.
    However, how you word an auction in B&S has an effect on determining if it is an offer or an invitation treat.

    Quote Originally Posted by reachme2003
    having bidded successfully and not fulfilling the financial obligation, as a result of, is an instance of 'non-payment' cases. right?
    I would think that it would depend on the nature of the auction. If it is a offer, an invitation to treat or others. If it is not an offer, than even if you have won the bid, there may not be any legal obligation. Though there might be a "moral" obligation.

    PS, just personal views.

  14. #14
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Jurong Lake District - West
    Posts
    897

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Quote Originally Posted by Ren_Hao
    I would think that it would depend on the nature of the auction. If it is a offer, an invitation to treat or others. If it is not an offer, than even if you have won the bid, there may not be any legal obligation. Though there might be a "moral" obligation.

    PS, just personal views.
    perhaps more like offer and counter offers....

    i guess at the end of the day is willing buyer and willing seller when the price is agreed on.

  15. #15

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Correction, the supermarket invites you to make an offer, ie you offer $X for product A. You are not accepting the offer, they are. When they take your money, they accept your offer and the contract is fulfilled.

    Wai Leong
    ===
    Quote Originally Posted by ernest_ted
    Things that are displyed on shelves on supermarket with price tag ==> invitation to treat not an offer.
    When u put the item in your trolley does not mean u have accepted the offer.
    Only at the check out when u pay, u have accepted the offer.

    Am i right....gee...contract law classes were many moons ago..

  16. #16
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    Beyond Space-Time Continuum
    Posts
    6,324

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Erm...most of the time, the both parties have not entered into a formal contract to buy and sell. It has always been, reserved for viewing, formal decision to purchase/buy has not been made until the buying party has reviewed and is satisified with the item.

  17. #17
    Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Sedna, Orion Stars
    Posts
    856

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    hmmm. ads in CS B&S are an "invitation to treat" and not an "offer" because the person in the ad does not show a willingness to enter into any legal relations with anyone as a result of the ad.

    hence, as a result, the seller actually has no obligation to sell to anyone.

  18. #18
    Deregistered
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    Asylum, Ward 4444
    Posts
    2,095

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    a contract comes into existance when there is an offer, acceptance & intention to create legal relation.

    & yes, the ads here r just an invitation to treat, not an offer.

  19. #19

    Smile Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    reading thru all these brings back my commercial law lessons many moons ago. then, there were no case law about transactions thru CS b&s. (CS did not exist then, huh!)

    my sell adv in b&s is an invitation to treat. when a party make an offer to buy at a price. i, as the seller accepts the offer and communciated it to the other party. would not a contract being 'inked' in such circumstances?

  20. #20
    Senior Member sykestang's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    studiospace
    Posts
    5,550

    Default Re: Does law of contract applies in CS B&S?

    Don't forget... there is still a consideration factor in Contract Law.
    Visit me at my studio: http://www.studiospace.com.sg

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •