So at the end of the day, if there are people who are willing to do photoshoots for commercial companies for free (because there are such people who are willing), should Clubsnap be a meeting place for them ?
"Yes": Free market, competition good for consumers, increase in standard
The "No" reasons i've seen are mostly because of personal opinion that it is demeaning to the photographer, or exploits the photographers. But if they are willing, why not ?
Another "No" reason might be that people who do it for a living might go out of a job, or start earning less as more and more people are doing it.
People who do it for free obviously isn't interested in the $$, but are in it for other things. This does not neccessary mean that their shots will be of a lower quality than one who does it for a living as well.
People who depend on it will of course think that such people "spoil market", but then, should Clubsnap support people who are "in it for other things" just people who want to earn $$ ?