Cokin P164 CPL or Screw-In CPL?

donchua · 29th April 2006

I am using a 77mm filter thread lens.
Have the Cokin P adapter.
Will it be better to get the Cokin P system P164 CPL or a one size 77mm screw-in CPL?
Which better?
Thanks.

Horsba85 · 30th April 2006

a screw in would be easier to use as the cokin troublesome to install the filter onto lens then mount glass. worse if it's a wide angle 77mm, the cokin portrudes so much out that it gives you some vignetting

29th April 2006	#1
donchua Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Tampines Posts: 7,814	Cokin P164 CPL or Screw-In CPL? I am using a 77mm filter thread lens. Have the Cokin P adapter. Will it be better to get the Cokin P system P164 CPL or a one size 77mm screw-in CPL? Which better? Thanks.

30th April 2006	#2
Horsba85 Member Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: Singapore Posts: 292	Re: Cokin P164 CPL or Screw-In CPL? a screw in would be easier to use as the cokin troublesome to install the filter onto lens then mount glass. worse if it's a wide angle 77mm, the cokin portrudes so much out that it gives you some vignetting