Shadows II

sumball · 2nd March 2006

Received comments on my other thread of the B&W shadow. This is another one shot at the same place with diffirent composition (slightly), in color, and with more shadows.

Hope to hear from the critiques or comments as usual.

Regards.

Ah Pao · 2nd March 2006

Alamak...one image per member per week lah...
http://forums.clubsnap.org/showthread.php?t=139941

However, compared with your previous pic, I'll prefer the b&w one. Adding in colour somewhat takes away the interplay between the light and shadows.

PS: Hope you won't repeat your mistake again!

sumball · 2nd March 2006

Ops! One per week ah... ok. Sorry, my mistake.

denniskee · 2nd March 2006

b&w better. this color one like not 3 not 4.

foxtwo · 2nd March 2006

depends much on how/what you want to present. grainy B&w for a cold, stark forbidden enclosed area with slits for light play. Or. Colour for an enclosed area with warm inviting inclinations.

no such comparision as which is better. perhaps i'm feeling particularly positive right now so i prefer colour. on other negative times b&w would suit.

what do you feel? and what do you want?

Stoned · 2nd March 2006

I prefer the other one because it's cleaner and more simple. This one has too much IMO.

2nd March 2006	#1
sumball Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2003 Posts: 4,224	Shadows II Received comments on my other thread of the B&W shadow. This is another one shot at the same place with diffirent composition (slightly), in color, and with more shadows. Hope to hear from the critiques or comments as usual. Regards.

2nd March 2006	#2
Ah Pao Member Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Singapore Posts: 1,578	Re: Shadows II Alamak...one image per member per week lah... http://forums.clubsnap.org/showthread.php?t=139941 However, compared with your previous pic, I'll prefer the b&w one. Adding in colour somewhat takes away the interplay between the light and shadows. PS: Hope you won't repeat your mistake again!

2nd March 2006	#3
sumball Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2003 Posts: 4,224	Re: Shadows II Ops! One per week ah... ok. Sorry, my mistake.

2nd March 2006	#4
denniskee Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2003 Location: bukit batok Posts: 4,212	Re: Shadows II b&w better. this color one like not 3 not 4. __________________ photography makes one sees things from all angles.

2nd March 2006	#5
foxtwo Senior Member Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: singapore Posts: 1,707	Re: Shadows II depends much on how/what you want to present. grainy B&w for a cold, stark forbidden enclosed area with slits for light play. Or. Colour for an enclosed area with warm inviting inclinations. no such comparision as which is better. perhaps i'm feeling particularly positive right now so i prefer colour. on other negative times b&w would suit. what do you feel? and what do you want?

2nd March 2006	#6
Stoned Senior Member Join Date: May 2004 Location: Changi Posts: 4,376	Re: Shadows II I prefer the other one because it's cleaner and more simple. This one has too much IMO. __________________ My Personal Folio (of random events and things)