View Poll Results: Will Russia surrender / sue for peace with Germany if Moscow is capture

Voters
43. You may not vote on this poll
  • Yes, it will surrender and sue for peace with Germany

    1 2.33%
  • No, it will fight on despite the loss of capital city

    41 95.35%
  • Not sure

    1 2.33%
Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 53

Thread: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

  1. #1
    Senior Member King Tiger's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2004
    Location
    In the heart of SengKang
    Posts
    5,882

    Default Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Operation Typhoon

    Germany launched Operation Typhoon on 02nd October 1941 with the aim of capture Moscow before Christmas.
    By 28th Nov 1941, the Germans are 30 km within the reach of Moscow.
    But winter, muddy ground, strong resistence, reinforcement from Russian Far East have already hinder Germans advance.
    On 05th Dec 1941, the reinforcement Russian force counter attack and push the Germans back.

    The discussion is : Will Russia surrender / sue for peace with Germany if Moscow is capture ?

    Prelude to Operation Typhoon
    Germany launch Operation Babarossa on 22nd Jun 1941 with the aim of defeating Russia in 6 months.
    (The operation was suppose to launch in May 1941 but was one month delay to due to Germany invasion of Greece and follow by Yugoslavia, in order to intervence and rescue her ally, Italy from military disaster.)

    Luftwaffe gain control of air supremacy quickly on the very first day, destroying 1200 Russian aircrafts.
    The massacre in the air was immediately followed by the one on the ground.
    Panzer divisions smash throught Russian defence, crushing and encircelment Russian armies after armies.
    German army have also uninterrupt air support from Luftwaffe.
    By 26th July 1941, German Army Group Centre have reach Smolensk, Russian defence have collapse and the road to Moscow was left open and undefend to the Germans.
    (But Hilter divert part of German Army Group Centre and Army Group South to capture a large Russian force around Kiev. The operation was a tactical success and 655,000 Russian troops was captured)

    By this time, Russian losses were extremely high.
    Before Operation Typhoon was launched, Russian have lost
    1) Almost every mechanised corps and 177 infantry divisions have been wipe out.
    2) 21,000 tanks
    3) 3,000,000 casualties (including KIA, MIA or POWs)




    P.S. Correct me if any of the above information is wrong.
    Purely military discussion only.
    Last edited by King Tiger; 12th January 2006 at 01:54 AM.
    War is one of the most regrettable human activities.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    The scenario brings to mind the phrase, "a cornered man is the most dangerous" (or something like that).

    The Russians are known for their fierce loyalty to their "motherland". Even with such high losses of men and equipment, I don't think they would have surrendered. IMO, it is quite likely they would have fought to the last man.

  3. #3
    Moderator Francis247's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Hougang, Punggol
    Posts
    6,627

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    IMO, Stalin is more focus on protecting Stalingrad even though Moscow is the capital city. So even if Moscow is lost, the Russian will try to resist the opposition from reaching Stalingrad at all cost and will try to push their way back to reclaim Moscow.
    莫问前程有愧,只求今生无悔. Time pasts, Places changed, Beauty faded, what is left are Photos of Memories…

  4. #4
    Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    1 Dalvey Road
    Posts
    474

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    believe moscow was saved by the fierce winter.
    was it early too?
    remember it was similar to napolean's situation.

    jude

  5. #5
    Member Taurean's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    White Elephants Town
    Posts
    1,700

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Yeah agree with Judeseah.

    Think the harsh winter conditions which the German troops are not used to cause them to retreat in the end. The German troops are not properly kit for the weather in Russia as well if memory didn't fail me

  6. #6
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Punggol 21
    Posts
    967

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Probably our second language would be German if Moscow was lost.
    I lup SG, but SG don't love me...

  7. #7
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2002
    Location
    Some equitorial, tropical isle
    Posts
    2,398

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Did you watch the foreign film Stalingrad?? Yeah, focused on that war. The winter was long and fierce. The German front was spread too thin. Support could not reach the troops thro the snow. Bogged down... not enough tracked vehicles. PLus heavy tanks were bogged down by the snow. Plus Germany was also fighting in Europe. Blitzkrieg would not have worked in this case.

  8. #8
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2003
    Location
    Outside the Dry Box.
    Posts
    16,268

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Quote Originally Posted by Sjourn
    Probably our second language would be German if Moscow was lost.
    technically that would make our 1st language japanese...
    Logging Off. "You have 2,631 messages stored, of a total 400 allowed." don't PM me.

  9. #9
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Hougang
    Posts
    820

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    The Germany troops were not properly equipped for Winter and the supply line was stretched too long. IMO this is the major cause for the defeat.

  10. #10
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    bukit batok
    Posts
    1,478

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    if any of you guys played codename panzers before,you would know a little bit of the german tanks not able to operate smoothly on snow especially panzer 3 and 4 divisons.
    only from their panther tank onwards (which they copied by stealing a T34),they start having a tank capable of matching the russian famous T34 tank with big and wide tracks to operate well on snow.
    but i guess the tiger and king tiger tanks really let them down due to more machine failure than being destroy.
    especially the tiger tank being heavy should best avoid muddy ground.

    the russian snipers also took out a few quite high ranking officers in stalingrad.
    to send german troops into low morale.
    Last edited by Simon_84; 12th January 2006 at 11:34 AM.

  11. #11
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2002
    Location
    Some equitorial, tropical isle
    Posts
    2,398

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Quote Originally Posted by Simon_84
    only from their panther tank onwards (which they copied by stealing a T34),they start having a tank capable of matching the russian famous T34 tank with big and wide tracks to operate well on snow.

    Ah.... the Panther, one of the best tanks of that era. I thought it was already fielded when operations in Russia takes place. Its just that there weren't enough. The only thing it learned from the russion tanks were the sloped armour.

    Just like the Me262... too few to win a war...

  12. #12
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    bukit batok
    Posts
    1,478

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Quote Originally Posted by Francis247
    IMO, Stalin is more focus on protecting Stalingrad even though Moscow is the capital city. So even if Moscow is lost, the Russian will try to resist the opposition from reaching Stalingrad at all cost and will try to push their way back to reclaim Moscow.
    in the film titled enemy at the gates,there was a russian general telling his officers to protect stalingrad at all cost because it bears the name of the boss.
    russian infantry were told to make a big dash in some parade square in stalingrad and cowards turning back were shot by their own russian people!
    forget what the name of the parade square but those who played call of duty before should roughly know.

  13. #13
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    bukit batok
    Posts
    1,478

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Quote Originally Posted by Zplus
    Ah.... the Panther, one of the best tanks of that era. I thought it was already fielded when operations in Russia takes place. Its just that there weren't enough. The only thing it learned from the russion tanks were the sloped armour.

    Just like the Me262... too few to win a war...
    some german troops were told to capture the russian prototype T34 tank when it came out during the early period of eastern front.
    the numbers of T34 produced is one of the major factors that that the russians start turning the tide.
    cause during that period no german anti-tank guns could pentrate the armor of the T34.
    a smashing success thats what the russians called it.
    it also create a major impact on all later allied tanks as well.
    not forgetting that 60 degrees angled sloped armor to defect incoming anti-tank shells.
    Last edited by Simon_84; 14th January 2006 at 12:51 AM.

  14. #14

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Unlikely. Mostly likely the russians will not surrender. They willl probably fight to finish and die. Imagine the Nazi signed the Non-Agression pact with the Russian when they invaded Poland and broke it when they invaded Russia. I dont think the Russian in their right mind would surrender to the Nazi who do not honour a pact. Moreover, the Nazi had already killed millions of russians.

  15. #15
    Member
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    At home
    Posts
    133

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    totally agree.

  16. #16

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    ok even tho this is Kopitiam but i have no wish to see it turn into a base for discussion of his nature. Even tho there may be many into military stuff and such but this is after all ClubSNAP, a place known more for it photography then of matters of that military natures.

    Thread will be closed and further threads of such nature closed without any further notices.

    To the thread starter. Pls be advised that if this thread go on, i think there will be more threads of such natures. I'm sure there are forums out there that cater to your needs.

    Hope to have your understanding and co-operation in this area.

    Mod
    Kopitiam

  17. #17

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    I have reviewed and reopened the thread for further discussion.

    My apology for the mod's wrong judgement call here.

  18. #18
    Senior Member afbug's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Planet SG™
    Posts
    483

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Quote Originally Posted by Jason Ho
    I have reviewed and reopened the thread for further discussion.

    My apology for the mod's wrong judgement call here.
    Thats cool. Thank you.

    I finally saw the T34 in action on TV just now. Did anyone of you watch Discovery's Top 10 tanks? Wow! T34's strength is its simplicity and sloped armour. Hi-tech at that time.

  19. #19
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2003
    Location
    Somewhere Out There
    Posts
    2,567

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Thanks for correcting the misjudgement...

    I agree that the russians will not surrender even if moscow is taken or even if stalingard is captured. Russia is so huge, the population is so vast, materials in abundance, why should russia surrender.

    As afbug pointed out, the T-34 were in production at a pace of 1,300 a month. What is there to stop the russians from taking captured territory back.

    Reminds me of Saddam when he was fighting Iran in the Iran-Iraq conflict that lasted for almost 10 years. In one engagement, Saddam lost thousands of men but the next day, he just whacked the Iranians the next.

  20. #20
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Punggol 21
    Posts
    967

    Default Re: Military Discussion : Battle of Moscow (Operation Typhoon 1941)

    Kudos to the admin

    It was a major under estimation of Germany to take on Russia, this piece of histroy was the turning point of the war. Had germany just stuck with Europe and anchored there, how long do you think the war would have lasted? my assumption would be 10 more years...
    I lup SG, but SG don't love me...

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •