Cokin filter system VS the others

rochkoh · 15th October 2002

Cokin has an interesting filter system. One which allows considerable reuse across most 35mm lenses, with adapters ranging from 48mm to 82mm.

But in terms of quality (build and image), how does it compare with those from Hoya and B+W? Investing in 77mm screw-on filters is expensive.

thanks in advance,
rOCh

ckiang · 15th October 2002

Cokin filters are made of resin, and they are probably not as good as those multi-coated glass ones by Hoya/B+W, etc. But it makes for a good filter system for someone starting out, etc. And for neutral density graduated filters, they are the cheapest. But some say the filters have a colour cast.

Regards
CK

kongg · 15th October 2002

The Lee filter system will cost an arm and 2 legs, (Maybe even 1/2 a head).........

jasonpgc · 15th October 2002

Quote:

Originally posted by kongg
The Lee filter system will cost an arm and 2 legs, (Maybe even 1/2 a head).........

A Small Lee Gel (plastic film type about 6.5 X 6.5 cm) for my flash cost about $17 from CP.

rochkoh · 15th October 2002

thanks CKiang,

i suppose there aren't any multi-coated Cokin filters around?

The cost of Hoya/B+W ND grad filters and Cir. Pols are the main reason why i'm considering the Cokin system. Am using mainly 77mm lenses with some 58mm and a 52mm. Getting separate filters for these will cost a bomb!

rOCh

Quote:

Originally posted by ckiang
Cokin filters are made of resin, and they are probably not as good as those multi-coated glass ones by Hoya/B+W, etc. But it makes for a good filter system for someone starting out, etc. And for neutral density graduated filters, they are the cheapest. But some say the filters have a colour cast.

Regards
CK

rochkoh · 15th October 2002

the Lee filter system??

Quote:

Originally posted by kongg
The Lee filter system will cost an arm and 2 legs, (Maybe even
1/2 a head).........

megaweb · 15th October 2002

There are other pro filters like

LEE filters
http://www.leefilters.com/home.asp

Singh-Ray Filters
http://www.singh-ray.com

Tiffen filters
http://www.tiffen.com/

ckiang · 15th October 2002

Quote:

Originally posted by rochkoh
thanks CKiang,

i suppose there aren't any multi-coated Cokin filters around?

The cost of Hoya/B+W ND grad filters and Cir. Pols are the main reason why i'm considering the Cokin system. Am using mainly 77mm lenses with some 58mm and a 52mm. Getting separate filters for these will cost a bomb!

rOCh

You can consider using step down rings.

But as far as ND Grads go, you have either the cheap Cokin, or the expensive Lee and SinghRay ones.

Regards
CK

15th October 2002	#1
rochkoh Member Join Date: Feb 2002 Location: Under your skin Posts: 582	Cokin filter system VS the others Cokin has an interesting filter system. One which allows considerable reuse across most 35mm lenses, with adapters ranging from 48mm to 82mm. But in terms of quality (build and image), how does it compare with those from Hoya and B+W? Investing in 77mm screw-on filters is expensive. thanks in advance, rOCh

15th October 2002	#7
megaweb Moderator Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: East Posts: 8,106	There are other pro filters like LEE filters http://www.leefilters.com/home.asp Singh-Ray Filters http://www.singh-ray.com Tiffen filters http://www.tiffen.com/ __________________ See my Photo Gallery at the Clubsnap \| Pbase

15th October 2002	#2
ckiang Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: Singapore Posts: 6,597	Cokin filters are made of resin, and they are probably not as good as those multi-coated glass ones by Hoya/B+W, etc. But it makes for a good filter system for someone starting out, etc. And for neutral density graduated filters, they are the cheapest. But some say the filters have a colour cast. Regards CK

15th October 2002	#3
kongg Member Join Date: Feb 2002 Location: Ang Mo Kio outskirts Posts: 784	The Lee filter system will cost an arm and 2 legs, (Maybe even 1/2 a head).........