Junk or Not ?

marcwang · 2nd May 2005

Some snaps from the other day. Do u reckon they are just snapshots, or do they have any art value ?

your comments much appreciated

Pablo · 2nd May 2005

Hi marcwang,

How about you shift the sequence...

Pic 1 to pic 3
Pic 2 to 2
Pic 3 to 1

Ahhh now I am confused

Just a thought.

Cheers

By the way, I think they look good in b&w as colour would loose it.

marcwang · 2nd May 2005

Hie Pablo,

These werent meant to be sequenced shots, so... I guess they should be viewed individually.

Thanks for your reply.

barracuda · 2nd May 2005

If I were you, probably I will junk #2 & #3, can salvage on #1.

my 2 cents...

marcwang · 2nd May 2005

Somehow the last picture, which appears to be least interesting, is my favourite. Somehow I look deeper into the picture, abit thought provoking. But the picture could be totally meaningless for others.

Adam Goi · 2nd May 2005

Hi.

I see potential in them ... perhaps add some witty captions?

Pablo · 2nd May 2005

Originally Posted by marcwang

Hie Pablo,

These werent meant to be sequenced shots, so... I guess they should be viewed individually.

Thanks for your reply.

Hi marcwang,

I see what you mean there (sorry I am not good at seeing things some times).
When looked at individually they are good shots by themselves !

Looked at this way... no... they are not just p&s shots, but more so abstract.

I am not good as a critique except for my own pics.

One thing that CS is good for apart from learning photo betterness (if that is a word); is that CS is also good for learning critique ness (if that is another word)

cy_j · 2nd May 2005

Beauty really is in the beholder's eye, as I personally find the second one to hold the best potential for human interest.

ndroo · 2nd May 2005

junk? you must be kidding. strange but true, i like them all, especially the 3rd one

marcwang · 2nd May 2005

The first one is starting to look abit gross, and warped. The longer I stare.

Do u get the mysterious feel about the person in the picture ? Like who is she... must be scary, cold, ... unwavering with time

thomaschan · 7th May 2005

i lik ethem.the birds look cute. makes me wanna go play with them.
especially the biting one.
its notti.

Originally Posted by marcwang

The first one is starting to look abit gross, and warped. The longer I stare.

Do u get the mysterious feel about the person in the picture ? Like who is she... must be scary, cold, ... unwavering with time

2nd May 2005	#4
barracuda Member Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: Singapore Posts: 618	If I were you, probably I will junk #2 & #3, can salvage on #1. my 2 cents... __________________ Come visit my blog

2nd May 2005	#5
marcwang Member Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: East Singapore Posts: 1,023	Somehow the last picture, which appears to be least interesting, is my favourite. Somehow I look deeper into the picture, abit thought provoking. But the picture could be totally meaningless for others. __________________ Marc Wang Photography

2nd May 2005	#9
ndroo Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: www.fuzzyeyeballs.com Posts: 6,714	junk? you must be kidding. strange but true, i like them all, especially the 3rd one __________________ fuzzyeyeballs

2nd May 2005	#10
marcwang Member Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: East Singapore Posts: 1,023	The first one is starting to look abit gross, and warped. The longer I stare. Do u get the mysterious feel about the person in the picture ? Like who is she... must be scary, cold, ... unwavering with time __________________ Marc Wang Photography

2nd May 2005	#1
marcwang Member Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: East Singapore Posts: 1,023	Junk or Not ? Some snaps from the other day. Do u reckon they are just snapshots, or do they have any art value ? your comments much appreciated __________________ Marc Wang Photography

2nd May 2005	#2
Pablo Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: Blue/Green Planet Posts: 1,854	Hi marcwang, How about you shift the sequence... Pic 1 to pic 3 Pic 2 to 2 Pic 3 to 1 Ahhh now I am confused Just a thought. Cheers By the way, I think they look good in b&w as colour would loose it. __________________ Time, is an effortless construction :)

2nd May 2005	#6
Adam Goi ClubSNAP Idol Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: Jalan Suka Posts: 5,321	Hi. I see potential in them ... perhaps add some witty captions?

2nd May 2005	#8
cy_j Member Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: Newton Posts: 727	Beauty really is in the beholder's eye, as I personally find the second one to hold the best potential for human interest.